Field Notes Lunacy Limited Edition Pocket Notebooks

December 10, 2016

It's been a long time since I've offered my impressions of a Field Notes Colors edition. I skipped several editions because they didn't speak to me enough (Workshop Companion, Sweet Tooth, and Snowblind), but started picking the notebooks up again with Byline and pulled the trigger on a subscription once I saw Lunacy. I'm glad I did, because so far I'm 2/2, with Lunacy and the current Black Ice edition both justifying the purchase. So here goes for Lunacy:

First Impressions

The first thing I want to say about these notebooks is that I absolutely love the cover. The material is a heavy textured stock ("Neenah Classic Crest 'Epic Black Stipple' 100#C") which almost feels like plastic. It's somewhat reminiscent of the covers on the Drink Local edition, only textured. I've not made it to "staple day" yet, but other than some slight wear on the edges, the cover on this notebook still looks almost new despite heavy pocket carry over the past two weeks.

Field Notes subscribers received two four-packs of the Lunacy edition, adding to the value of your subscription. The all-black notebook is subscriber-exclusive. More of my thoughts on this below. — Field Notes subscribers received two *four*-packs of the Lunacy edition, adding to the value of your subscription. The all-black notebook is subscriber-exclusive. More of my thoughts on this below.

I initially worried that the glossy "moon" peeking through the die-cut covers would be a bit much and make the notebook too "busy" looking for professional use (i.e., in meetings for my stodgy office job, where silly things like "individualism" and "creativity" are frowned upon). Having these notebooks in hand, I'm not too worried. The end result is much more understated than you'd first expect, probably because the rest of the notebook is blacked out, from the embossed "Field Notes" logo and moon on the front and back covers, to the black staples, to the gray reticle-grid paper. That said, I probably will use the all-black subscriber-exclusive notebooks first, then the crescent moon notebooks, then the quarter moon, and finally the full moon, mainly because I worry the cutouts will snag on things in my pocket and my bag and end up not lasting as long as they should.

Paper Quality

Lunacy is one of the most fountain-pen friendly Field Notes editions I have used. Honestly, the paper may handle fountain pen ink better than any other edition I've tried. (Take that with a grain of salt - I like my Field Notes, but I'm not an addict to the point where I can say I own or have tried them all.)

Two fountain pen inks tested on the Lunacy paper. The Bookbinder's Everglades Rat Snake (the orange) did really well, with the Montblanc Burgundy feathering a little in a very wet nib. There was absolutely no show-through or bleed-through with eithe… — Two fountain pen inks tested on the Lunacy paper. The Bookbinder's Everglades Rat Snake (the orange) did really well, with the Montblanc Burgundy feathering a little in a very wet nib. There was absolutely no show-through or bleed-through with either ink.

Even though this paper handles the ink well, for some reason I still don't find this paper particularly pleasant for fountain pens. While there's minimal feathering and absolutely no bleeding, I've experienced a scratchy "draggy" sensation when writing on this paper with fountain pens, likely caused by the fibers. I suspect using a more lubricated ink might help, but lately I've been perfectly content to use my Baron Fig Squire and Steel and Flint pens for most of my pocket notebook writing, both kitted out with the Schmidt Easyflow 9000 refill.

Takeaways and Where to Buy

The only way you can get the all-black notebook pictured here is by starting a Field Notes Colors subscription beginning with Lunacy. Lunacy subscriptions seem to still be available as of the time of writing, but I imagine they may close out soon since Black Ice has been released. Act quick!

If you're interested in picking up a regular Lunacy three-pack, Pen Chalet has them in stock, and you can use the current HOLIDAY discount code to snag them at 10% off the $12.95 sticker price. (It's also a good opportunity to pick up the Black Ice edition!)

Thoughts on the Field Notes Colors Subscription Service

Since I offered my thoughts on the Baron Fig subscription service(s) last week, I thought I'd take a moment to discuss my impressions of the Field Notes Colors subscription. To my knowledge, Field Notes was the first pocket notebook company to offer a subscription service, and they continue to surprise everybody with the sheer breadth of their creativity and ingenuity in developing and executing new ideas. Most of their limited editions have earned rave reviews, some were a little out-there and off the beaten track (Sweet Tooth, anyone?), but I haven't spoken with many people who consider their Field Notes subscription a "bad investment." Why? Because by any measure it represents good value for someone who is a fan of Field Notes products and/or uses a lot of pocket notebooks.

When you subscribe to Field Notes Colors, your first package contains not only two packs of the latest Field Notes Colors limited edition (currently the awesome-looking "Black Ice"), but you also receive two packs of the classic Kraft paper original Field Notes, and some "extras" like Field Notes pencils or pens. Going forward, you receive two three-packs of each new Field Notes Colors release, along with more "extras", some of which are subscriber exclusives (like buttons, etc.). This year, subscribers also received a special surprise in the form of a personalized reprint of the first two Field Notes Colors editions: Butcher Orange and Butcher Blue. Since Field Notes has used this "special shipment" as a selling point to attract new subscribers, I expect they will do something similar in the future.

The cost of a subscription is $97, shipping included. By purchasing all of items listed above separately (not including subscriber-exclusive "extras"), the cost would easily exceed $115. If you like Field Notes, and buy all of the special editions anyway, it makes financial sense to subscribe. That said, you do bear the risk that you'll get one or more editions you aren't crazy about. If that happens to me, I plan to do what I do every year to clear out my stationery overstock: Christmas gifts and stocking stuffers for the rest of my family!

Disclaimer: I paid for my Field Notes subscription with my own money, for my own enjoyment, and have not been compensated for this review. This post contains affiliate links.

Pen Review: Lamy 2000 4 Color Ballpoint (Multipen)

December 7, 2016

So I finally caved and bought it. After sitting in my Amazon cart for most of the year, last week I pulled the trigger and ordered the Lamy 2000 Multi Pen (which Lamy refers to as the 4-Color Ballpoint), and this is another of those purchases where I'm kicking myself for waiting as long as I did. This is hands-down the best multi pen I have ever used.

Fit and Finish

Makrolon + Brushed Stainless Steel = Classic Design

No surprises here. This pen is pure Lamy 2000, from the brushed Makrolon finish to the stainless steel spring-loaded clip and knock. It resembles a slightly girthier Lamy 2000 ballpoint pen, and I've found that the added width makes it more comfortable to hold for longer periods of time. This pen looks stunning in a three-pen holster along with my Lamy 2000 fountain pen and ballpoint. I'm tempted to finish out the set by picking up the rollerball and the .5mm mechanical pencil, especially since I've read that the rollerball can be hacked to take a wide variety of common refills, including Montblanc fineliner and Pilot G2 refills.

Gravity-Driven Color Changing Mechanism

By far the coolest thing about this pen is how you switch between the different colors. At the back of the pen, around the knock, there is a series of colored panels in blue, red, and green. To change colors, you rotate the pen so that the color you wish to use is facing you ("black" is the clip), then press the knock. Once you're finished, press the knock again to retract the refill, rotate to select a new color, and repeat. It's mind-bogglingly simple to use, and it baffles me how Lamy can come up with this idea and execute it in such a way that the mechanism works perfectly nearly every time.

One note: while you can use any color refill in your Lamy 2000 Multi Pen, the color references will always show black, blue, red, and green. There's no way to change the colors on the body of the pen itself, BUT many D1 refills also have a splash of color around the tip for reference purposes. If you venture outside the black-blue-green-red range of colors, it might otherwise be easy to forget what you have in the pen.

Some D1 refills, like this red Uniball Jetstream, have a colored ring around the tip so it's easy to recognize which color you're about to write with.

Refill Options

The big downside to D1 refills is that they are small and therefore don't last very long, especially the gel versions. (Zebra Sharbo X gel refills are excellent, but they can get very expensive very fast if you're using your multi pen for more than quick notes here and there.) To get more mileage out of your refills, I'd recommend sticking to ballpoint or hybrid ballpoint refills. Based on what I've used so far, I'm most impressed with the Uniball Jetstream D1 in .5mm. I have these loaded into the blue and red slots in my Lamy.

Just to give you an idea how small these refills are. Uniball Jetstream and most other Japanese refills are sold individually (I'm currently using the packaging to store the stock Lamy refills that came with the pen), but Monteverde and Schmidt sell… — Just to give you an idea how small these refills are. Uniball Jetstream and most other Japanese refills are sold individually (I'm currently using the packaging to store the stock Lamy refills that came with the pen), but Monteverde and Schmidt sell their refills in packs of four.

In terms of standard ballpoint refills, the stock Lamy refills are fine, but they can be a bit light in certain colors, especially the red and the green. I purchased a couple packs of the Monteverde Softroll D1 refills in blue-black and orange, since I'm generally a fan of Monteverde ballpoints. The blue-black is nice, and I currently have it loaded in the "black" slot, but the orange looks gross (brownish in color and way too light to be usable). I have a pack of the Schmidt D1 refills on the way, so we'll see how they turn out. I'm a huge fan of Schmidt's Easyflow 9000 and the D1 version has received good reviews.

For a complete discussion of the various D1 refill options, I highly recommend that you visit Ana's Epic Refill Guide over at the Well-Appointed Desk. It's comprehensive and will give you a good idea of what's out there. In my experience, JetPens and Amazon typically have the widest selection of D1 refills.

Takeaways/Where to Buy

I consider the Lamy 2000 4 Color Ballpoint to be the gold standard of multi pens. It's well-built, reasonably priced, and takes a readily available refill style that's not proprietary. Given the small size of the refills, they can be expensive to own as your primary writing instrument if you plan on using them for something like journaling or writing extensively in longhand, but I've always appreciated multi pens as annotation and note taking tools.

The Lamy 2000 4 Multi Pen can be somewhat difficult to find from traditional pen retailers, because it's a bit of a niche product. [2023 Update: Over the years, I became frustrated with how few retailers were carrying the Lamy 2000 ballpoints and focusing on the non-fountain pen portion of Lamy’s excellent lineup, so I became a retailer! You can now purchase the Lamy 2000 line of pens, including the 4-color ballpoint, directly from T.G.S. in the Curated Shop.]

Further Reading. There are tons of Lamy 2000 Multi Pen reviews out there. To name just a few, check out reviews by Bob at My Pen Needs Ink and Azizah at Gourmet Pens.

Disclaimer: I purchased this pen with my own funds for my own collection. This post does not contain affiliate links.

Baron Fig: The Black Box and Thoughts on Stationery Subscription Services (Spoiler Warning!)

December 3, 2016

You may have heard that Baron Fig recently announced a massive number of new quarterly subscriptions: one for each of their main product lines, including the Confidant hardcover notebook, the Vanguard softcover notebook, the Squire pen, and the Archer pencil. The idea behind stationery subscription services is pretty simple: subscribers will be among the first to receive limited edition versions of the Company's products that are issued on a quarterly basis. Once you subscribe, you don't need to take any further action in order for the latest and greatest to show up at your door.

The Black Box Is a Big Winner, for Me

So far, Baron Fig has announced two limited edition notebooks that subscribers will receive. The first was the Work/Play II, a reboot of last year's acclaimed Work/Play Confidant. More on that below. The second is the Black Box, a run of limited edition Vanguard notebooks that I absolutely love, and that I'm going to talk about first.

The theme of the Black Box is "Mysteries." Each Black Box contains three softcover Vanguard notebooks (the medium-sized, A5-ish "Flagship" size) featuring Baron Fig's excellent dot grid paper and a black cover with different "mystery-themed" illustrations in unique colors. The three mysteries are (by my best guess) The Bermuda Triangle (yellow), Bigfoot/Sasquatch (Green), and UFOs (Red). As a fan of The X-Files, Supernatural, Stranger Things, insert-scifi/horror series here, these are a huge win for me.

I've reviewed Baron Fig notebooks before, so I don't see a need to talk at length about the paper quality, etc. here. In short, Baron Fig paper is very good, and will hold up to most pens, though you may see bleeding and feathering with especially wet or broad fountain pens. I really enjoy writing on Baron Fig paper with pencils, and I think it's among the best pencil-friendly paper available. What I would like to talk a bit about, however, is the flak that Baron Fig has taken during the initial rollout of their subscription services, some of which I think is unfair and fails to take into account the nature of Baron Fig's products and who their end users are.

For some reason I really love those stylized trees.

My Thoughts on Baron Fig's Subscription Strategy

It surprised everyone that a company would take the unprecedented step of announcing a quarterly limited-edition subscription service for ALL FOUR of their major product lines. It's an ambitious move fraught with a lot of risk. Baron Fig is a small shop, and it will take a lot of work for their team to maintain the existing business while attempting to develop fresh ideas for four different limited editions on a quarterly basis. That's 16 special editions a year across all of the product lines. Companies like Field Notes, Write Notepads, and Palomino-Blackwing do four.

One thing I'd love to see Baron Fig do is include some great extras with their subscriptions - like these "Manifesto" stickers they sent me with my Black Box.

Before Baron Fig had even announced any new editions, chatter started on blogs, Twitter, forums and podcasts saying that "there was no way" Baron Fig could come up with "inspired" or "unique" ideas for each one of these limited editions. Predictably, when Baron Fig announced the Work/Play II as the first limited edition Confidant, it was criticized as just "a reissue" of a past L.E. (despite the fact that the past Work/Play was highly acclaimed and sold out in days, leaving many - myself included - disappointed and empty-handed). Even the Black Box has been minimized as "just a new cover on a pre-existing notebook." IMHO, the critiques of the Work/Play II have some validity, but the snipes at the Black Box are unfair. (The first year's worth of Field Notes Colors were essentially standard graph-paper notebooks with different color covers and rulings. It took Field Notes a while to get to where they are now). Additionally, I think both overlook why many people would subscribe to Baron Fig products in the first place.

It's easier for a company like Field Notes and Write Notepads to take risks with crazy designs on smaller items like 48-page pocket notebooks. Even if you get an "out there" edition with your Field Notes subscription, like Sweet Tooth or Expedition, you can still find some use for them, whether it be as substitutes for post-it notes (Sweet Tooth) or a garage/car notebook (Expedition). This is harder to do with a larger notebook or a journal. Personally, if I'm subscribing to a service that sends me four large 100+ page notebooks a year, I want a bit more predictability. That's not saying that I'm paying in advance for four reissues - I want to see some creativity - but I also want to be sure that I will receive four Confidants or larger Vanguards that I can reliably use. Baron Fig's following is also smaller than that of Field Notes, and I'd venture to say that a larger percentage of them tend to be professionals who use their notebooks daily for work. I'm not above carrying and using some absolutely insane notebooks, but if I were to subscribe to a service, I'd want some comfort that the notebooks I was going to receive wouldn't stray too far from what I've come to expect from my daily-driver Baron Fig books.

From this perspective, I like what I've seen so far from Baron Fig, and would gladly pay a subscription price to receive products like the Black Box and Work/Play II. With respect to the Work/Play II, it may not have been the best launch strategy to lead with a reissue, but the original Work/Play was such a huge hit and sold out so quickly that I see it as a perfectly legit business decision to kick things off by giving your hardcore fans - those most likely to subscribe - what they've been asking for.

To date, Baron Fig has put a lot of thought into their products. Everything I've reviewed from them has been high quality and - importantly for me - highly practical and usable in my daily life. I'm perfectly willing to give them the benefit of the doubt until they have had, at a minimum, a year or so under their belt with the subscriptions before trying to declare whether it's been a success or not. Enough on this from me. Enjoy your weekending and Holiday decorating!

Disclaimer: Baron Fig sent me the Black Box notebooks featured in this review at no charge. I was not otherwise compensated for this review, and the views expressed here are just like, my opinion, man. If you disagree with me on anything, I'm sure you'll let me know. :)

Notebook Review: MOO Hardcover Notebook

November 30, 2016

While many excellent notebooks pass through my hands on a regular basis, you can only use so many, forcing you to make some hard choices if, like me, you have a never-ending (and ever-growing) stockpile/backlog. That said, I think that the new MOO Notebook is going to make the decision on what I'm using next pretty easy.

The Moo Notebook ships in a slipcase, which will look outstanding on your shelf once you're finished filling your notebook.

MOO is a stationery company perhaps best known for their high-end business cards and other business stationery. They recently released their first notebook, and were kind enough to offer me one for review. How do I like it? Well, I've already purchased two more (along with a swanky leather business card holder).

MOO is known for their packaging, and a lot of thought and attention obviously goes into it.

First things first: this is a classy-looking hardcover notebook, starting with the packaging. The notebook that I received came packed in a black gift box, and included a matching slipcover and pencil. The notebook itself is hardbound in charcoal/gray cloth, with lime green highlights on the inside cover to make things interesting. The notebook also came with an embossed MOO pencil! If you're looking for a gift for a notebook lover this holiday season, look no further - the Moo Notebook will impress. NOTE: (Please see my update at the bottom of this post about retail packaging compared with what I received, which is apparently a promotional bundle.)

A few samples of additional MOO stationery ship with the notebook.

The MOO pencil included with my notebook, labeled "Go Forth and Write." A nice touch!

So what about the paper? It's fairly heavy Munken-Kristall (Swedish) ruled paper that is suitable for most pens. None of the pens that I tested bled through, including fine and medium nib fountain pens, though I suspect that if you took a super wet stub or broad nib to this paper you might have a different experience. For the vast majority of people, however, this paper will do just fine. I personally would prefer a narrower ruling (or even graph or dot grid), but I can - and will - use this paper without an issue.

The MOO Notebook features 160 ruled pages of Swedish Munken-Kristall paper. I saw no bleed-through or show-through with any of the various pens and inks that I tested.

A couple design features make the MOO notebook unique from anything else I've seen on the market. The first is the binding. MOO uses a coptic-style binding, with a cover that separates from the spine in order to allow the notebook to lay flat more easily. The second is the inclusion of a seam of blank light green paper in the middle of the notebook that you can use as sketch paper, or even as a divider to break the notebook into different sections.

The MOO Notebook's unique binding and center seam

I worry that recently I've sounded like a bit of a broken record, giving high marks to most of the notebooks I've reviewed. After thinking on it, however, it's because much of what is coming onto the market these days is just that good. I love the fact that the majority of new notebooks that I've had the opportunity to try have been fountain pen-friendly. It finally seems that notebook manufacturers are starting to "get" what stationery enthusiasts are looking for, and realize the extent of the demand out there for nice-looking books with good paper.

Price Point and Where to Buy

You can buy these notebooks directly from MOO online, and you all are lucky! Until December 5, 2016, you can get the MOO notebook for $13.99 (!!??!), which is 30% off the already reasonable retail price of $19.99. I did a double take when I saw that one, then promptly ordered two more. Most of MOO's other goods are on sale as well. It's probably safe to say that you won't find a better quality notebook at the $13.99 price point, provided you like the aesthetics.

Even at the regular price point, given the overall quality of this product, $19.99 is a steal. When I first opened the box and saw the notebook, I would have pegged this as a $30 product, easily. Kudos to MOO for putting this out there at an accessible price. The MOO Hardcover Notebook should do well, and I look forward to seeing whether or not MOO introduces graph or dot-grid versions in the future.

Update

I heard from the folks at MOO, who let me know that the Black Box and Pencil are special promotional packaging for the notebook's launch. Notebooks purchased from the MOO website will include just the hardcover notebook and the slipcover. My apologies for any confusion, but at the MOO Notebook's attractive price point, the packaging issue doesn't change my opinion that this is still an excellent deal and would make a nice holiday gift!

Disclaimer: I received this product from MOO free of charge for review purposes, though I have since purchased additional books using my own funds. I was not otherwise compensated for this review.

Introducing the Pencil Crown, from Elegant Utility

November 29, 2016

Here's something for all you pencil fans out there. Elegant Utility, an Etsy seller based in Long Island, New York, has developed a neat product that adds better balance to uncapped pencils. The product is called the Pencil Crown, and it's a small piece of brass, slightly larger than your typical ferrule + eraser, that slides over the end of the pencil.

The Pencil Crown should fit most untipped pencils fairly easily.

I'm one of those people that ordinarily prefers a pencil with an eraser because I think, in general, they are more comfortable to write with. The weight of the ferrule gives the pencil a more comfortable balance in your hand, and the Pencil Crown makes up for this on a pencil that otherwise lacks an eraser. Technically, you can use the Pencil Crown with any pencil, provided you first remove the ferrule or dipped end, but I think I'll end up using this more for uncapped pencils like the Caran d'Ache Grafik pictured here.

The Pencil Crown gives a nice weight to pencils that I would otherwise find too light.

A huge thank you to Michael at Elegant Utility for sending this Pencil Crown over for review. If this product interests you, please visit the Elegant Utility Etsy store. In addition to the Pencil Crown, Elegant Utility also sells a version of the Pencil Crown with an eraser, the Pencil Pal (best described as their version of the bullet pencil), and the Pencil Companion (a pencil holder/extender), among other unique objects.

Disclaimer: The Pencil Crown was sent to me free of charge by Elegant Utility for review purposes.