The question above is one that I get regularly. Just as fountain pen enthusiasts are extraordinarily particular about paper, pencil enthusiasts also have their preferences, and people regularly approach me for “pencil paper” recommendations. What’s interesting is that fountain pen and pencil preferences can be diametrically opposed: certain smooth, coated papers that work well with fountain pens can feel too glassy and smeary with graphite; whereas more textured, tactile papers that appeal to pencil enthusiasts might catch on a pen nib and/or be too absorbent for water-based inks.
What Are My personal Pencil Preferences?
This is an “Ask TGS” post, so it goes without saying that my answer here is colored by my own personal preferences, which favor a more tactile writing experience when using pencils. I tend to like pencils with graphite on the scratchier side, and seek out paper with texture somewhat akin to a sketchbook. That’s what I think of as “pencil paper”. Yes, there are people who prefer smoother paper with pencils, in part because it won’t wear the point down as quickly and won’t require sharpening the pencil as frequently. If you value point retention, definitely take this into account. Personally, I enjoy pausing periodically to sharpen the pencil, as it forces me to slow down and periodically reflect. YMMV.
Appointed’s heavy-duty spiral “The Notebook” has become a pencil favorite.
Papers That I Love with Pencil, In No particular order
Blackwing Paper. Predictably, Blackwing Paper was designed with pencils in mind, and I’ve always found that the Slate notebooks and “Illegal Pads” strike a good balance between texture and functionality. They’re textured enough to feel satisfying with pencil, yet not too rough to use with pens. I’ve had very good luck using Blackwing paper with most fountain pens.
Baron Fig Paper. I have a large stock of Baron Fig “Mastermind” Desk Pads that I purchased years ago, so it’s possible the paper has changed as Baron Fig has reconfigured a lot of their product line, but as originally reviewed the Mastermind paper was excellent paper for pencils. Fountain pens can be hit or miss, though I always find the paper adequate for most everyday tasks where I’m using one of these tear-off desk pads. Notsu’s Writing Pads are similar.
Appointed Paper. I discovered Appointed last year when I was shopping in New York City and picked up one of their top-bound spiral to-do pads. I fell in love with this paper for pencil, even if it’s too absorbent to use with fountain pens broader than a fine. Appointed Paper has what I’d consider to be a near-perfect texture for pencils and might be my new standard for graphite.
Midori MD Cotton. One of my favorite “middle ground” workhorse papers for when I want to use fountain pens, pencils, and other inks interchangeably, Midori MD Cotton has subtle texture and exceptional ink-friendliness for a more absorbent cotton paper. If Midori offered this paper with rulings (like they used to), it would easily be my primary writing paper.
Any Sort of Laid or Textured Paper (G. Lalo, Original Crown Mill, Bindewerk). There’s definitely a balance, because overly textured paper can cause lead breakage with longer points and mechanical pencils, but traditional laid or linen-textured paper can be fun to use with pencils. Most of these papers also handle ink well, though some users dislike heavier texture with a fountain pen nib or pen tip, especially finer points or sharper shapes like stubs and architects that can get caught in the ridges.
While I hope you find this helpful, there’s no substitute for your own experimentation. This can be hard to explain to in-store customers or pen show attendees: some people want there to be an undisputed “best paper,” but the most I can offer is starting point. Enjoy the exploration, as that can be the best part of the hobby. The great thing about paper is that it’s expendable. If you keep writing, you’ll eventually use it up and you can try something different!
Come see us in-store this week and try some of this for yourself! We are open from 1pm-6pm Thursday and Friday, and with reduced hours from 9-11am this Saturday (I have a family event to attend.) I will likely have some make-up hours Sunday afternoon.
