Major paper brands don’t change much over the years. The predictability of brands like Midori, Clairefontaine, Maruman, Kokuyo, and others are a big reason why they remain so popular. You know what to expect, and larger companies (usually) manufacture their own products, so they buy paper in large quantities and maintain a healthy supply on hand in case of disruption. For example, this is why Hobonichi was able to continue producing its planners using the “old” Tomoe River Paper for years after it was discontinued.
Smaller boutique brands, on the other hand, usually have to outsource manufacturing and nearly always have to source their paper from a third party. As a small business owner myself, I know firsthand how difficult it is to source materials - especially when you can’t afford to purchase multiple years’ worth of supplies at once - and maintain consistent results from any sort of outside contractor. But as a retailer who sells many different brands, as well as an enthusiast who loves to support smaller makers, it also means that I have to periodically test certain smaller-batch products to make sure paper stock (and performance) hasn’t changed.
Archer & Olive has one of the few hardback A5-Slim notebooks available.
Over the past year, I’ve made an effort to add to our curation smaller makers whose paper has been consistently high-performing, including with fountain pens. While I continue to watch any small boutique brand closely for things like paper stock, these five have performed consistently enough while I’ve had them in the shop that I can comfortably recommend them to anyone looking to try something different.
Notsu. I discovered Notsu by chance, when I was buying up samples of different brands of index cards looking for a dot grid layout with paper/cardstock capable of handling fountain pen inks. Not only have their index cards remained consistently good, but Notsu has been adding new formats and expanding their line of organizational accessories that almost make it an index card notebook system.
Lochby. I love Lochby’s waxed canvas covers and planners, but my favorite Lochby product line is the 68gsm Tomoe River Paper Notebooks. I’ve heard mixed rumors about whether or not the 68gsm Tomoe River Paper is still being made by Sanzen, so I’m encouraged by the fact that you cannot only still get it through Lochby but that Lochby is continuing to release new formats, including B5, TN (A5-Slim), and A7.
Levenger. As a lifelong user (sort of an exaggeration but not much) of Levenger products, I’ve learned to hoard their writing pads and Circa disc-punched paper when they source a good batch, because it has been inconsistent for fountain pen users over the years. The current version that we carry is wonderfully fountain pen friendly and I really hope that Levenger sticks with this paper supplier. If you’re looking for meeting-style or Cornell-ruled notetaking paper, the Annotation-ruled pads are a personal favorite.
Archer & Olive. I’ve only recently discovered Archer & Olive, which makes 160gsm notebooks that handle ink beautifully and are also really nice for writing. Best of all? Archer & Olive notebooks come in an A5-slim/TN/Traveler’s-equivalent hardcover format that’s the best I’ve seen since the old Soumkine notebooks. The notebooks come in either fabric or vegan leather covers, with a range of motifs. I’ve heard via customers who have used their products over the years that Archer & Olive has remained consistently good, so I’m likely going to bring in additional formats.
Anecdote. I picked up one of Anecdote’s buckram-covered A5 notebooks in a store somewhere in NYC years ago, and was thrilled to be able to add them directly to our store. While the paper seems to have changed a couple of times, it’s remained fairly fountain pen friendly for most nibs and inks, and the $20 price point makes this an attractive everyday notebook. Buckram behaves a lot like waxed-canvas in terms of texture and how it patinas.
Smaller brands also experiment more with different formats, like this week-on-a-page planning pad from Notsu.
If you’d like to read more about fountain pen friendly papers and which ones I personally like, check out this long-running (and annually updated) post “Hierarchies of Fountain Pen Friendly Paper”, as well as this post from earlier this week where I talk about my favorite of the fountain pen friendly papers.
The Gentleman Stationer is supported by purchases from the T.G.S. Curated Shop (our online store) and pledges via the T.G.S Patreon Program. Come see these and more in our Nashville shop, where we are open from 1-6pm on Thursday and Friday, and from 10am-6pm on Saturday!