Five Boutique Paper Brands I'm Watching Closely and Why

Major paper brands don’t change much over the years. The predictability of brands like Midori, Clairefontaine, Maruman, Kokuyo, and others are a big reason why they remain so popular. You know what to expect, and larger companies (usually) manufacture their own products, so they buy paper in large quantities and maintain a healthy supply on hand in case of disruption. For example, this is why Hobonichi was able to continue producing its planners using the “old” Tomoe River Paper for years after it was discontinued.

Smaller boutique brands, on the other hand, usually have to outsource manufacturing and nearly always have to source their paper from a third party. As a small business owner myself, I know firsthand how difficult it is to source materials - especially when you can’t afford to purchase multiple years’ worth of supplies at once - and maintain consistent results from any sort of outside contractor. But as a retailer who sells many different brands, as well as an enthusiast who loves to support smaller makers, it also means that I have to periodically test certain smaller-batch products to make sure paper stock (and performance) hasn’t changed.

View fullsize

Archer & Olive has one of the few hardback A5-Slim notebooks available.

Over the past year, I’ve made an effort to add to our curation smaller makers whose paper has been consistently high-performing, including with fountain pens. While I continue to watch any small boutique brand closely for things like paper stock, these five have performed consistently enough while I’ve had them in the shop that I can comfortably recommend them to anyone looking to try something different.

1. Notsu. I discovered Notsu by chance, when I was buying up samples of different brands of index cards looking for a dot grid layout with paper/cardstock capable of handling fountain pen inks. Not only have their index cards remained consistently good, but Notsu has been adding new formats and expanding their line of organizational accessories that almost make it an index card notebook system.

2. Lochby. I love Lochby’s waxed canvas covers and planners, but my favorite Lochby product line is the 68gsm Tomoe River Paper Notebooks. I’ve heard mixed rumors about whether or not the 68gsm Tomoe River Paper is still being made by Sanzen, so I’m encouraged by the fact that you cannot only still get it through Lochby but that Lochby is continuing to release new formats, including B5, TN (A5-Slim), and A7.

3. Levenger. As a lifelong user (sort of an exaggeration but not much) of Levenger products, I’ve learned to hoard their writing pads and Circa disc-punched paper when they source a good batch, because it has been inconsistent for fountain pen users over the years. The current version that we carry is wonderfully fountain pen friendly and I really hope that Levenger sticks with this paper supplier. If you’re looking for meeting-style or Cornell-ruled notetaking paper, the Annotation-ruled pads are a personal favorite.

4. Archer & Olive. I’ve only recently discovered Archer & Olive, which makes 160gsm notebooks that handle ink beautifully and are also really nice for writing. Best of all? Archer & Olive notebooks come in an A5-slim/TN/Traveler’s-equivalent hardcover format that’s the best I’ve seen since the old Soumkine notebooks. The notebooks come in either fabric or vegan leather covers, with a range of motifs. I’ve heard via customers who have used their products over the years that Archer & Olive has remained consistently good, so I’m likely going to bring in additional formats.

5. Anecdote. I picked up one of Anecdote’s buckram-covered A5 notebooks in a store somewhere in NYC years ago, and was thrilled to be able to add them directly to our store. While the paper seems to have changed a couple of times, it’s remained fairly fountain pen friendly for most nibs and inks, and the $20 price point makes this an attractive everyday notebook. Buckram behaves a lot like waxed-canvas in terms of texture and how it patinas.

View fullsize

Smaller brands also experiment more with different formats, like this week-on-a-page planning pad from Notsu.

If you’d like to read more about fountain pen friendly papers and which ones I personally like, check out this long-running (and annually updated) post “Hierarchies of Fountain Pen Friendly Paper”, as well as this post from earlier this week where I talk about my favorite of the fountain pen friendly papers.

The Gentleman Stationer is supported by purchases from the T.G.S. Curated Shop (our online store) and pledges via the T.G.S Patreon Program. Come see these and more in our Nashville shop, where we are open from 1-6pm on Thursday and Friday, and from 10am-6pm on Saturday!

What's On Your Desk? My Personal Favorite Papers for Fountain Pens, 2025

Over the weekend I updated the long-running post “Hierarchies of Fountain Pen Friendly Paper” to reflect new products on the market and changes in availability of certain papers that I consider “fountain pen friendly”. I don’t believe that I’ve ever written a designated post discussing my personal favorites from that list, so here goes!

How I Use Paper and How It Affects My Preferences

Because this post addresses my own personal preferences, I should probably talk about what those are first. For my personal writing, I enjoy using more textured, relatively absorbent paper with a softer writing feel. My primary considerations are (relatively) quick dry times and the ability to write on both sides of the page. Because I use a lot of planners and ring or disc notebooks, I also value perforated pages, or at a minimum, paper that comes in tear-off pads or looseleaf sheets that can be hole-punched or cut down to different sizes. What don’t I pay a lot of attention to (at least beyond the basics)? The nuances of ink color and shading/sheen/shimmer, since most of my writing is more functional and not retained long-term, and also because I think Midori MD Cotton - my favorite - does a more than adequate job with ink. Three of the papers on this list are long-timers (both Midoris and the Tomoe River 68gsm), and two are recent additions (Soliste and Maruman Basic).

1. Midori MD Cotton. My all-time favorite writing paper, even if it mostly comes in blank, unruled notebooks and writing pads. Midori MD Cotton strikes an excellent balance between absorbency and ink-friendliness, will dry relatively quickly without feathering or bleeding, and for those who do value color reproduction, actually does a pretty nice job of showcasing inks. I was sad to hear at this year’s San Francisco Pen Show that Plotter is not going to continue to make the A5 and Bible-sized refills featuring the MD Cotton Paper with letterpress ruling, which is what is shown in the pictures here.

2. Yamamoto Soliste. A relatively new paper that Yamamoto has popularized, the off-white Soliste is uncoated and textured, yet not quite as absorbent as MD Cotton Paper. I find that it has a soft feel, which is especially noticeable when used in notebooks like the Yamamoto Ro-Biki system. If you enjoy the feel of papers like Iroful or Cosmo Air Light, but desire something slightly less “spongy” (for lack of a better term) consider giving Soliste a try.

3. 68gsm Tomoe River Paper. Each year, as we watch the “classic” 52gsm Tomoe River Paper undergo production changes and reformulations, I worry about the 68gsm version, which is my favorite of the two. Slightly heavier, and in my opinion, more textured with better dry-times and performance for everyday writing, this is my favorite paper to use in A5-Slim/Traveler’s-size notebooks ever since Lochby introduced its own “Voyager” refill. Currently, third-party companies Lochby and Odyssey notebooks are the only ones who I know who are using the 68gsm version in large quantities, and I worry that eventually it will run out since I don’t believe it is being produced any longer. Hopefully I’m wrong.

4. Midori MD Paper. I would also include Plotter paper under this header. While standard Plotter paper is marketed as a different product and has a different formulation, it comes from the same product family and for my purposes behaves similarly. I love Midori paper for the variety of layouts, ranging from blank or grid pads to dot grid colored paper to memo blocks to letter pads.

5. Maruman Basic (70 gsm). I was late to the party on this one, but I was happy to discover this cost-effective fountain pen friendly paper that I enjoy using for work. Slightly lighter weight than Maruman Mnemosyne, I don’t see much of a drop off in performance, and the sturdy spiral binding and chipboard cover has held up well in my bags. Also: perforated pages! I can’t emphasize how nice that is!

View fullsize

I wish Midori would expand its use of the cotton paper, like the limited edition Plotter refill shown here. MD Cotton is my personal ink swatching paper of choice, even if some would argue that it darkens the colors.

If I’m drawing or playing around with ink purely for personal enjoyment, there’s a 90+% chance I’m using Midori MD Cotton. For notetaking and everyday work, however, I will probably be using the Maruman Basic Spiral Notebooks or some version of Midori MD Paper (including the various Plotter refills). These papers strike a good balance between performance and cost-effectiveness, and come in a wide range of different rulings and formats.

If I had one recommendation to those looking for that “perfect” paper: test as many different papers as you can. Paper is still relatively inexpensive, so it’s easy to buy a handful of different notebooks and samples to dial in your preferences once you have a general idea of your overall needs and what you think you like. Pen clubs and shows are often great places to test out different papers, as people are usually willing to share. Finally, we keep samples and testers of most papers available in our shop, so if there is something you’d like to see or write on, I will often be able to go get it for you. It gives you a reason to come see us!

Our brick and mortar store is open this week from 1-6pm Thursday and Friday, and from 10am-6pm on Saturday. You can of course always shop with us online, 24-7!

View fullsize

Maruman Basics Dot Grid Paper: An everyday workhorse.

Hierarchies of Fountain Pen Friendly Paper: Updated Resource!

I’ve spent the last two days updating the site resource “Hierarchies of Fountain Pen Friendly Paper,” which was originally a blog post first published in 2021. It’s garnered such a good response - 50+ comments at last count - that I’ve left it in blog format just to maintain the active comment section. I periodically update the main article to account for changes in paper performance, new brands, and customer/reader feedback. Because I can’t test everything, I leave the comments open for suggestions.

What Were the Major Developments in 2025?

I added a handful of brands to the resource, and removed one or two others mainly due to availability issues. Here are the major changes:

• Write Notepads Drops Off the List. Write Notepads left the direct-to-consumer market, at least for now, to focus on B2B sales. While I understand that may change in the future, for now their products are not as widely available so I’m leaving them out of this resource which focuses primarily on retail products.

• Stàlogy and Blackwing Move Into Tier I. While I’ve considered these two brands “Tier II” fountain pen friendly paper in the past, I’ve noticed an increase in consistency so I’ve moved both of them into Tier I. With Blackwing, note that this refers only to their standard paper. Some of their special edition notebooks may use different paper which may or may not perform similarly.

• Notsu and Shorthand Make an Appearance. These two brands make new appearances in Tiers I and II, respectively. Notsu is one of my favorite new stationery brands out there, and their ink friendly index cards have become a staple of my personal rotation. Los Angeles-based Shorthand makes a wide range of notebooks, notepads, and correspondence stationery, and while I would limit fountain pens to extra-fine or fine nibs, I love the feel of their vintage-y off-white paper and sturdy covers and spiral bindings.

Note that this is not intended to be a “ranking,” and the order in which these papers appear in each tier are not intended to suggest that any one is objectively “better” than another. Also, even non-fountain pen friendly paper can be quality stationery. Certain high-end cotton papers are tactile and highly absorbent - quite pleasant to write on with pencil, ballpoint, and rollerballs - but they can’t handle the water-based ink found in most fountain pens. Enjoy, and as always, drop a comment if you have suggestions on paper I may not have tried.

The Gentleman Stationer is supported entirely by purchases from the T.G.S. Curated Shop and pledges via the T.G.S. Patreon Program. If you’d like to see any of the papers mentioned here in person, or even try some of them, come by our brick-and-mortar shop located in Nashville!

View fullsize

Unpacking the Fountain Pen Friendly Paper Sampler: Why a Sampler, and Why These Specific Papers?

I mentioned last week that a frequent request I receive for the shop is the sampler pack, namely fountain pen friendly paper and woodcase pencils. It’s somewhat counterintuitive: what’s the rationale behind paying $10 for 15-20 sheets of paper when you can get a full 50-pad sheet for the same price? The answer is that the “value” is in the money you don’t need to spend, something that really hit home as I’ve spent the past two weeks cleaning out my day job office as I prepare to go fully remote. I have multiple bankers’ boxes full of paper and notebooks that I purchased simply to test the paper - money I likely would not have needed to spend had there been readily available ways to test some of these brands and formats via sampler packs and pads containing different brands.

View fullsize

For further reading on Fountain Pen Friendly paper, check out this post, which I try to update fairly regularly and which has a lively comments section.

I still have a fair number of our Fountain Pen Day paper samplers - I ended up making more than my originally intended 15 - and I’ll continue to make them available for purchase online and in-store as long as my current supply of sampler paper holds out. After that, I will consider whether to re-up on the current sampler and/or expand what I offer. For today’s post, however, I thought it might be fun to talk a bit about each of the papers in the current fountain pen friendly paper sampler, how I personally have used it, and why I chose to include it in this initial pack. (Note: These papers are discussed in the order in which they appear in the sample pack, not any order of personal preference.)

• Write Notepads Paper. While there have been supply constraints recently (it’s a very small company), Write Notepads still makes some of my favorite cost-effective fountain pen friendly paper. It also comes in a wide variety of formats, from writing pads to hardcover notebooks to spiral and pocket notebooks. I know that many products are showing as out-of-stock, but they are on order. Fingers-crossed for a restock in the near future!

• Life Bank Paper. Life Bank Paper is a classic, “professional” paper that is one of my favorite off-white options. The A5 Bank Paper pad is a favorite of many for letter writing (this watermarked paper just looks classy) and it handles fountain pen ink extremely well with reasonable dry times.

• Life Noble Note. With a different (smoother?) feel than the Bank Paper, Life’s “Noble Note” paper is their standard workhorse offering. While excellent for fountain pens, I also find it pleasant to use with pencils.

• Rhodia. I included Rhodia mainly for comparison purposes. A sibling company of Clairefontaine, the papers are slightly different, with Rhodia - in my experience - slightly less fountain pen friendly but rather cost-effective if what you’re looking for is paper that performs well enough to be usable without breaking the bank.

• Clairefontaine Triomphe. Known for their bright white, extremely fountain pen friendly paper stock, Clairefontaine is probably my “inexpensive” paper of choice, if I had to name one. The Triomphe pads are marketed as suitable for correspondence, but they are also just as useful for general writing and notetaking. Clairefontaine recently released a series of softcover A5 notebooks using the Triomphe paper.

• Standard Clairefontaine Looseleaf and French-Ruled Looseleaf. Clairefontaine makes relatively inexpensive looseleaf paper, which is one thing I love about the brand, especially since it’s available in the Seyes/French-Ruled variant. This is the same paper used in the non-Triomphe notebooks and notepads, so you can use the looseleaf sheets in the sampler to see how this paper works for you.

• Life Airmail “Onionskin” Paper. While this paper may not appeal to everyone, I went ahead and included it in the paper sampler because its an interesting, non-mainstream paper option that has some historical significance. Onionskin paper was used to reduce postage rates for “airmail” being delivered long distances, and while no longer necessary, it’s a fun throwback, and it’s frankly kind of wild to see how well this ultra-thin paper handles fountain pen ink. (You’ll also note that the paper is back in stock - I found my stash of onionskin that had “disappeared” in the move.)

When you compare the various papers in the sampler, you will definitely find that some work better for you than others. However, some of them are more expensive than others, and you may have to pay for “peak” performance. As someone who has used a LOT of paper in their job over the years, I’ve personally focused on finding everyday paper that is good enough to handle the fine and medium fountain pens I use most of the time. For me, that’s typically some combination of Write Notepads, Clairefontaine, and Midori MD (which I may feature in another sampler later on). While I may not get to it in 2024, given that the holidays are already upon us and I’m barely keeping it together as it is, I would love to continue to offer this and other samplers going forward.

The Gentleman Stationer is supported by purchases from the T.G.S. Curated Shop and pledges via the T.G.S. Patreon Program. We recently opened a physical location, where we can see customers a few days a week and where you can test many of the papers discussed here in person. See the “About” page for updated hours, which are subject to change.

Ask TGS: Where Do I Start with Paper for Notebook Systems?

I'm regularly asked: "How do I get started?" The sheer number of different brands of paper and notebooks now available on the market can be overwhelming to those new to the world of high-end and imported stationery. Lately, it's become one of the more common questions I receive, especially at pen shows from those interested in building out a planner or notebook system but not knowing where to begin.

Any paper recommendation depends heavily on intended use, but in my experience most new users (and most everyday writers in general) are looking for a versatile, multi-purpose paper that they can use with a fairly broad range of writing instruments and, in the case of fountain pens, different inks. Most people want the ability to use their notebooks both at work and for fun. Given that, I try to direct people to paper that balances "ink-friendliness" with reasonable dry times. There are plenty of paper options out there that fall into this category, and which are relatively inexpensive to boot, so it shouldn't be cost-prohibitive to experiment with a few different brands and find the paper that works best for you.

View fullsize

The Lochby Field Journal can hold up to six slim A5 notebooks, or two thicker A5 notebooks. It’s a universal A5 size allows you to use different notebooks from all sorts of different brands, in an seemingly endless universe of layouts.

A Note on How These Recommendations are Set Up

Given my personal focus on notebook systems and covers, I typically get this question from people looking for refills for their new system binder from Lochby, Roterfaden, or another similar company. The recommendations below are therefore framed in terms of slim A5 notebooks. However, the same considerations apply to people looking to try good paper in general, and all of the companies listed below make their paper in a wide range of sizes and formats, including spiral notebooks and pads. And even with notebook systems, you’re not limited to the slim A5 notebooks (as shown in the picture above). You just won’t be able to carry as many at once.

• Midori MD Paper: I usually recommend that people start here, in either the standard MD notebooks or the three-packs of slimmer MD Light notebooks. (I can't tell a difference between the paper and I think it's the same.) For those who want to carry multiple inserts in a cover system, the MD Light notebooks will work best, but if you want to stick with one or two thicker notebooks, then go with the standard MD notebook. The reason why I love Midori paper, especially for those looking to test out good paper for the first time, is because the paper is somewhat absorbent and strikes a good balance between ink-friendliness and dry times.

• Nakabayashi Logical Prime Threadbound Notebooks. I discovered Nakabayashi paper last year, and it's proven extremely popular due to the fact that it's very fountain pen friendly, ink dries quickly, and the unique multi-lined ruling is reminiscent of Clairefontaine French-ruled paper without the longer Clairefontaine dry times. The slim A5 threadbound notebooks are most popular for the various "system covers", but there are other formats in different sizes. All of the various types of paper handle fountain pen ink well, including the lighter Logical Air and the heavier Yu-sari.

• Lochby Tomoe River 68gsm Notebooks. I have always preferred the heavier, slightly more absorbent 68gsm Tomoe River paper over the lighter 52gsm version, at least for everyday use. I've found that it has a faster dry time, and also resists tearing and wrinkling, making it a preferred choice for the office. That said, I've not been able to find much information on the future of this paper. Tomoe River Paper is now being manufactured by a new company, and while Lochby still has stock of the 68gsm paper, I suspect it will eventually be phased out given that it's (unfairly, IMHO) less popular than its lightweight counterpart. Lochby does have some interesting ruling options in this format, including Wide Ruled and Undated Planner layouts, which you can't easily find elsewhere.

View fullsize

But What About the Traveler's Company Traveler's Notebook?

The Traveler's Notebook system is a bit of a different animal because it’s a proprietary size. While there are non-Traveler's branded refills out there in different papers, most of the "official" refills use some version of Midori MD Paper (most of the standard refills) or 52gsm Tomoe River (Lightweight Paper). I usually recommend that people interested in the Traveler’s Notebook start with the standard MD Paper refills (one blank refill is included with your cover) and then switch to the Lightweight Paper or Sketch or Watercolor Papers if they need something different.

View fullsize

All of these recommendations are just a starting point. As I mentioned up top, once you find a core paper that works for most of your everyday writing, you can experiment and start trying different specialty papers and other brands. My favorite aspect of a multi-refill notebook cover (a "notebook system") is the ability to carry many different papers at once and switch back and forth as you go. (The next thing you know, you're a nut like me, with three different systems in rotation all at once, because you know you need to use all the papers!)

For further reading, be sure to check out our guide to fountain pen friendly papers, which has an active comments section in addition to the papers I’ve personally tried.

The Gentleman Stationer is supported entirely by purchases from the T.G.S. Curated Shop and pledges via the T.G.S. Patreon Program. If you enjoy our content, we greatly appreciate your support!