• Blog
  • Shop
  • Resources
  • FAQ (Ask TGS)
  • About
  • Archive
  • Contact
  • Sign In My Account
Menu

The Gentleman Stationer

Vintage Living in the Modern World.
  • Blog
  • Shop
  • Resources
  • FAQ (Ask TGS)
  • About
  • Archive
  • Contact
  • Sign In My Account

First Impressions: Monarca Inks

February 23, 2022

It’s easy to get overwhelmed by the sheer volume of ink available in today’s fountain pen market, and even I have trouble keeping the various brands straight (not to mention the literally hundreds of individual colors out there). To me, those brands that stand out are those that make an effort to cultivate a true sense of identity, often by drawing on their place of origin. Such is the case with the latest arrivals, a series of nine inks from Monarca Stationery inspired by the colors of Mexico’s landcapes.

Monarca color swatches, still wet. The inks dry fairly quickly but these were wet swatches with the side of a Drillog on Tomoe River Paper.

The colors themselves are gorgeous - a balanced mix of dark and vibrant with a special edition shimmer ink (Rey Jaguar) thrown in. Colors include: Manglar (Mangrove), a dark green; Mar Caribe (Caribbean Sea), a bright turquoise; Nopal (Cactus), another green; Cardona (Cactus Fruit), a burgundy/red with sheen and shimmer; Arena Blanca (White Sand), a light sandy brown; Cenote, a deep blue with sheen and shimmer; Cielo Cruel (Cruel Sky), a shading grey-blue; and Tierra Colorada (Red Soil), a deep reddish brown.

Cardona, a dark burgundy-red inspired by cactus fruit, is one favorite that I plan to get into rotation soon. Writing samples in this post were all done with a Drillog Metal Dip Pen (in a much better .8mm kindly sent to me by the manufacturer), on 68gsm Tomoe River Paper in a Lochby Notebook.

I’ve very much enjoyed the design work that Monarca put into packaging their ink. The boxes themselves look like works of art, with images of the Mexican coast, rainforest, and semidesert, depending on which scene inspired a particular color. Each box contains a bottle of 30ml ink along with a banak wood ink stand/pen rest, particularly helpful if you are using these inks with a dip pen. The one downside I’ve noticed with Monarca inks is that the mouth of the bottle is very narrow, making it impossible to fill even medium-gauge fountain pens like the Pilot Custom 823 unless you decant the ink into a different bottle or a sample vial. (You will likely also have to do this once the ink level in the bottle gets low, given it’s tall, narrow shape.)

Monarca ink swatches when dry. The most interesting of these inks, even if not my preferred colors for everyday use, are the Arena Blank and Rey Jaguar.

For a “real world” writing test, I loaded Cielo Cruel and Mar Caribe into two Parker 51s from my collection (original vintage on the right, Nick Pang Fantasy 51 on the left). So far, they’ve performed well on nearly all papers but I will follow up after some long-term use.

Takeaways and Where to Buy

While this is just a “first impressions” review, and I’ve not had an opportunity to extensively test all inks in the Monarca lineup, Cielo Cruel and Mar Caribe have shown themselves to be excellent daily writers, with no feathering, no bleed-through, and relatively quick dry times. I look forward to rotating the rest of these inks through my pens, especially some of the more unusual colors such as Arena Blanca and Rey Jaguar.

You can purchase Monarca inks directly via the Monarca Stationery Etsy shop, or via authorized U.S. retailers including Dromgoole’s and Amarillo Stationery. Ink is currently sold either individually in 30 ml glass bottles starting at $20 USD ($24-29 for shimmer inks), or as part of a full set containing all nine inks for $180. Smaller four-color bundles are also available. Despite having to travel from Mexico and clear customs, shipping was incredibly fast.

Disclaimer: I received the set of nine inks featured here from Monarca Stationery, free of charge, for review purposes. I was not otherwise compensated for this review, and this post does not contain third-party affiliate links. Many thanks to Monarca for making this review possible!

In Ink Reviews Tags Monarca Stationery, Ink Review, First Impressions
5 Comments

Ink Review: Vinta Aegean Armada and Leyte Sea Kelp

February 5, 2022

I included both Vinta and Ferris Wheel Press in my year-end review as favorite ink lines that I discovered in 2021. This was somewhat unusual for me - typically I avoid boutique inks, particularly those from non-pen manufacturers that focus on special properties such as sheen, shading, and shimmer. Not that these inks are dangerous to use in your pens - they hardly ever are - it’s just that they don’t usually work well for everyday writing, and I value inks that dry quickly and perform decently on cheap paper given the demands of my day job. Vinta seems to have found a sweet spot in their formulation, however, because nearly all of the inks I’ve tried not only work well in most fountain pens and on most papers, but they dry fairly quickly and, with respect to the “shaders”, remain legible even in extra-fine (and ultra extra-fine) nibs.

Vinta Aegean Armada

After avoiding the color family for the better part of my pen “career,” I’ve developed a bit of a thing for grey inks over the past six months. Currently, my two favorites are Scribo Grigio and the ink pictured here, Vinta Aegean Armada 1944. Inspired by the Battle of Leyte, the largest naval engagement in military history, Armada was designed to mimic the color of a fleet of ships reflected onto the sea, “which can transform its color from grey to blue to everything in between.” Armada shades beautifully - in finer nibs it will appear as a darker grey, and with broader nibs you will see some double shading that includes steel blue and even faint pink hues. Armada behaves very well on most papers, even cheap office paper as long as you use a finer nib.

Vinta Aegean Armada was one of the most difficult inks to photograph accurately - it’s hard to show the pinkish/reddish double shading that comes through as the ink dries, but you can sort of see it here.

If I had to pick an ink to which I could compare Armada, it would be Iroshizuku Fuyu-Syogun, only darker and with slightly more depth to keep it interesting. I’ve tried to love Fuyu-Syogun (“Old Man Winter”), but it’s just not quite legible enough for me to use in everyday writing.

All writing samples shown here (and in most of my recent ink reviews) are on Write Notepads bright white paper. The Leyte Sea Kelp writing sample was done with a JoWo No. 6 18k Gold Nib (in a Kasama Una fountain pen), and the Aegean Armada writing sample was done with a Lamy AL-Star medium steel nib.

Vinta Leyte Sea Kelp

In another nod to Philippines history, Vinta’s Leyte “Sea Kelp” green pays tribute to not only the Battle of Leyte Gulf in 1944, but the area’s kelp industry. Leyte green is intended to evoke “the color of kelp as it floats in the bright clear seawaters of Leyte.” I’ve been looking for a solid mid-tone green ink, and this one perfectly fills that gap in the collection.

Vinta Leyte undergoes a bit of a color shift as it dries. In the first picture, it appears darker when wet, but as the ink dries it takes on a slightly more yellow-olive hue.

Takeaways and Where to Buy

Count me in as a big fan of Vinta Inks. I have three bottles in my current collection, as well as a handful of samples, so look for more reviews to come. Vinta regularly releases new colors and store collaborations, so keep an eye on their website and social media for updates.

I love the design of the Vinta Inks bottle and packaging.

You can purchase Vinta Inks directly from the manufacturer, located in the Philippines, or from authorized retailers around the world. Our friends at Vanness Pens stock the entire Vinta lineup, which is where I acquired the inks pictured here. Vinta Inks come in 30ml amber glass bottles, priced at $12.50, placing Vinta in the lower-middle price segment. In my opinion, they’re excellent value given the combination of quality and unique colors and properties they offer.

I purchased the inks featured in this review at Vanness Pens, with my own funds for my own use, though I did receive a discount on the purchase. This post does not contain paid third-party affiliate links, and I was not otherwise compensated for this review. The Gentleman Stationer is supported by purchases from the T.G.S. Curated Shop and the T.G.S. Patreon Program.

In Ink Reviews Tags Ink Review, Vinta Inks, Inks
Comment

A New Ink for the New Year: Birmingham Ancho Chili Pepper

January 8, 2022

Last year I placed my first order with Pittsburgh-based Birmingham Pen Company, and ended up with a handful of interesting colors. The first ink I reviewed was Angelfish, one of their “Rich” formulation inks, and I particularly enjoyed the fact that this sheeny blue ink dried quickly and didn’t bleed, smear, or feather in the same way that many other super-saturated inks have a tendency to do. I’ve actually had Angelfish inked up since I reviewed it, and would even go so far as to call it a potential workhorse.

A second Birmingham ink I’ve enjoyed is Ancho Chili Pepper, one of those colors that defies description, in that it’s a greenish-brownish-grey, which on some papers shows purplish or red undertones, especially when still wet. Ancho Chili Pepper features Birmingham’s “Crisp” formulation, meaning that the ink has been crafted to perform well on “a variety of premium, mid-range, and discount papers.” For me, this screams “workhorse ink,” and I can confirm that this ink largely lives up to its promises.

The brown and reddish tones are most visible when the ink is still wet. As it dries, Ancho Chili Pepper takes on a more green-grey hue.

For one thing, the muted color fits me perfectly, in that it not only falls into my one of my personal favorite color schemes (dark greens, or should I say “green-ish inks”), but it’s the sort of office-appropriate muted color that stays interesting while not being overly ostentatious. I’ve found this ink performs quite well on high-end and mid-range papers, though I did experience some minor bleed-through and a touch of feathering with cheap copy paper. (I suspect it might perform better in a narrower nib - my long-term test pen has been a medium TWSBI Diamond 580 Rose Gold II, and I’ve found the rose gold plated TWSBI nibs to write a wetter line than their steel equivalents.)

Birmingham Pen Company 30ml Bottle

I always opt for the smaller, 30ml bottle, but if you really enjoy certain colors you can purchase as much as 120ml of ink in an eyedropper bottle for only a minor upcharge.

I continue to be impressed with Birmingham inks, which can only be ordered directly from the Birmingham Pen Company website, including Ancho Chili Pepper. Most inks are available in 30ml, 60ml, and 120ml bottle options, and Ancho Chili Pepper is reasonably priced at $13, $16, and $19, respectively. The inks are hand-mixed in small batches, so certain colors go in and out of stock, but keep checking back if what you want is not available at the moment.

I purchased the ink featured in this review with my own funds, for my own personal use. This post does not contain third-party affiliate links. T.G.S. is supported by purchases from the T.G.S. Curated Shop. If you would like to support us even further, please consider checking out the T.G.S. Patreon Program, which offers access to online meetups, exclusive discounts and pre-orders, and more!

In Ink Reviews Tags Birmingham Pen Company, Ink Review, Workhorse Inks
1 Comment

Private Reserve D.C. Supershow Blue: A Classic Returns

December 4, 2021

Private Reserve Ink has really been through the wringer over the years, passing through the hands of three separate owners and finally ending up in the hands of Yafa, the current owners/distributors of Monteverde and several other brands. One of the original boutique ink brands that existed alongside Noodler’s from the time I entered the hobby, I’ve had mixed success using Private Reserve throughout my “pen career.” When I first started out, these inks were the only option you had if you wanted highly saturated reds, greens, and blues, but those colors often came with a lot of baggage in the form of slow dry times/smearing, a tendency to stain, and at one point, a propensity to grow mold due to a formulation error. Fortunately, these issues were eventually sorted out, and the new inks exhibit none of these problems. In fact, they’re quite good.

Private Reserve DC Supershow Blue pops off the page, in the way that many inks haven’t done since Parker discontinued the Penman Sapphire.

To answer the question of “Just how good?”, during my recent visit to Anderson Pens I selected a bottle of what was once one of the highest-maintenance fountain pen inks out there: Private Reserve D.C. Supershow Blue. A saturated blue originally designed to mimic long-discontinued cult ink Parker Penman Sapphire, the old formulation of Supershow Blue was, for me, impossible to use. I found that it never dried, and would clog pens to the point that I would have to prime the feed by twisting the converter a bit any time I stopped writing for more than a day. That said, Supershow Blue is an absolutely gorgeous color, so if Yafa’s most recent take on Private Reserve rendered this color useable, it would be a huge win for everybody.

DC Supershow Blue and its characteristic red sheen - only this time no smearing!

TLDR version: The latest version of this ink is great. To test out dry time/smear resistance, I layered it onto Write Notepads dot grid paper with a folded nib dip pen, and experienced absolutely no bleedthrough or feathering. Importantly, the ink dried relatively quickly, and after a few minutes you could run a finger across the page without any smearing or stickiness whatsoever - impressive since the ink is fairly wet. The color isn’t quite a match for Parker Penman Sapphire (see the comparison in the photo below), but it stands on its own as a great “bright blue” option.

So at this year’s Chicago Pen Show, the ink testing table contained a sample of Penman Sapphire, which I compared against the new formulation of Supershow Blue. The old Penman Ink has more of a violet hue, with additional red sheen. It does, however, smear much more than the Private Reserve, even two months later.

Takeaways and Where to Buy

Given how nice my experience with this ink has been, I’m definitely looking at picking up some additional colors. Private Reserve is widely available from most pen retailers, and generally inexpensive. As I mentioned, I purchased the bottle featured in this review at Anderson Pens Chicago. Most of the standard colors are priced at $15 for 60ml, quite a good deal, with specialty inks such as the “Infinity” series and the “Pearlescent” shimmer inks commanding a slight premium. Another longtime Private Reserve favorite is “Burgundy Mist,” which I reviewed relatively recently, and I look forward to revisiting both Sherwood Green and Tanzanite, inks that were once staples of my collection.

People either love or hate the Private Reserve Ink bottles. They feature a large volume (60ml) and a wide opening for easy filling with larger pens, but these bottles do tend to spatter/spill a bit since they always ship very full. Exercise care when opening!

Disclaimer: This post has been revised to reflect/disclose that as of June 2025, T.G.S. is now a retailer of Private Reserve Ink! You can purchase a selection of the Private Reserve Colors directly from our shop.

In Ink Reviews Tags Private Reserve, Blue Ink, Ink Review
Comment

Chicago Trip Ink Haul: Several from Sailor Ink Studio & Sailor Manyo HaHa

November 20, 2021

It’s been that kind of week: I’m just now getting around to unpacking my bags from last week’s Chicago trip, before I turn around and head out the door again on Tuesday for the Thanksgiving holiday here in the U.S.! I have a few review posts in the works, but couldn’t help sharing my initial swatches of five different Sailor Inks I picked up at Anderson Pens Chicago. Consistent with my latest obsession, all of these inks are double-shaders that, despite some initial hesitation, appear to be quite legible and might make good everyday writers. Also, look at the color shift in the ink as it dries! (And yes, I know I got the numbering wrong in the writing sample. 242 should be 252.)

A little bit of a “time lapse” photo here, when the ink was still wet.

Time lapse part 2: Check out the color change as the inks dry, especially on Ink Studio 173 and 280. Sailor Manyo HaHa is one of the prettiest double-shading blues I’ve seen.

I’m becoming a bigger fan of both Sailor Ink Studio and the Sailor Manyo inks, the more I use them. Sailor inks are always well behaved, and the Ink Studio line features dozens of unique colors unlike anything I’ve seen elsewhere. Currently, you can only find these inks at select Sailor retailers, including Anderson Pens which carries the inks online and in their Appleton, Wisconsin and Chicago stores. For the record, the inks featured in this post are as follows: Sailor Manyo Haha (50ml, $19), Sailor Ink Studio 252 (20ml, $18), Sailor Ink Studio 173 (20ml, $18), Sailor Ink Studio 280 (20ml, $18), Sailor Ink Studio 670 (20ml, $18). Look for some more follow-up observations as I get these into rotation and work them through some pens.

This post does not contain affiliate links. I was not compensated for this review, and I purchased the inks with my own funds, though I did receive a slight discount on the purchase. Many thanks to Anderson Pens for making this review possible.

In Ink Reviews Tags Sailor Ink Studio, Anderson Pens, Anderson Pens Chicago, Ink Review
Comment
← Newer Posts Older Posts →
Store Hours and Location
Visit the T.G.S. Curated SHOP
*New* Updated "Best Pens" Guide (2025)
TGS x Hinze Pens Violet Tendencies Taschenstift Fountain Pen
Hierarchies of Fountain Pen Friendly Paper
Allex Scissors arrayed on a desk showing link to desk accessories

Join Our Patreon!
Subscribe to the TGS E-mail List

Featured Posts

Featured
Iro-Utsushi-Fine-Dip-Pens.jpeg
Oct 1, 2025
The Pilot Iro-Utsushi Dip Pen (and in General, Simple vs. Fancy Dip Pens)
Oct 1, 2025
Oct 1, 2025
Levenger-Annotation-Pad.jpeg
Sep 20, 2025
Five Boutique Paper Brands I'm Watching Closely and Why
Sep 20, 2025
Sep 20, 2025
Playing-ink-MD-Cotton-Glass-Pens.jpeg
Sep 17, 2025
What's On Your Desk? My Personal Favorite Papers for Fountain Pens, 2025
Sep 17, 2025
Sep 17, 2025
The Gentleman Stationer RSS

© Digital Divide Media, LLC, 2014-present.

All content is the exclusive property of Digital Divide Media, LLC, d/b/a The Gentleman Stationer, including “The Gentleman Stationer” website and trademark, and should not be reproduced without express written permission.  All rights reserved.

All content containing paid advertising, affiliate links, or sponsored content will be plainly disclosed by a disclaimer when/if featured.

Contact Information

Store Shipping Policy and Return Policy

Privacy Policy

Cookie Policy

Terms and Conditions

Powered by Squarespace