It’s been too long since I’ve devoted a full post to the Kanilea Pen Company. I purchased my first Kanilea pen, a Mauna Kea, back in March 2017 at the Baltimore Pen Show. In the meantime, I’ve added two more to my collection: a Nui Nalu and a Hanauma Bay (from their “Elements” and “Locations” collections, respectively). In my earlier post, I went over the history of the brand, and particularly how Hugh and Karol Scher launched Kanilea based on their family’s travels to and love of Hawaii. I’ve regularly remarked on how I consider Kanilea to be one of the most unique well-conceptualized, and well-implemented “small batch” pen brands. (By “small batch,” I mean pens that aren’t made-to-order custom pens in a material/design chosen by the customer, but rather come from a standard product line, made in extremely small quantities and, in the case of Kanilea, entirely by hand.) Regardless of whether or not you find the aesthetic of the pens appealing, you have to appreciate what Hugh and Karol have done with the brand in such a short period of time.

So let’s catch up and talk about what’s special about my two latest Kanilea additions:

The Nui Nalu (“Big Waves”) fountain pen was inspired by the waves on the North Shore of O’ahu. I chose this particular pen due to how the white swirls were both evenly distributed through the material AND formed a continuous “wave” pattern. It’s not as obvious in my pen, since the darker swirls and “whitecaps” are more prominent, but sections of the acrylic are slightly translucent, allowing you to see the converter or, alternatively, the ink should you choose to eyedropper the pen. I also selected a different shape from my Mauna Kea, opting for the Classic rather than the Classic Flush, so the cap on this pen is slightly oversized.
The Hanauma Bay fountain pen, from the “Locations” collection, was inspired by a photograph of a sunset over Haunauma Bay, O’ahu. The pen is definitely one of the wilder pieces in my collection, with the acrylic featuring swirls of green, gold, white, turquoise, blue and orange, and the orange and blue showing a good degree of translucency. Most notably, my Hanauma Bay is a “Classic V” shape with a sterling silver clip, and this design posts, which distinguishes it from most of the other Kanilea models. The pen is a bit long posted, but it’s also quite light due to the acrylic construction and cartridge-converter system, so I can easily post it when I don’t have a convenient place to set the cap down.

Premium design and construction warrants a premium price. Kanilea Fountain pens start at $395 for a pen with a steel nib, with gold nibs $125 extra, and rose gold nibs $135. The acrylics are custom made for Kanilea, and the pens are all hand-turned. Trim (clips and medallions) are sterling silver, and nibs are all tuned by Hugh prior to shipping. Finally, most people ignore (or throw out) the packaging from their pens after purchasing, but you’ll want to hang onto your wooden Kanilea box, which makes a great keepsake or pencil box for your desk. I’ve found ways to use all three of them!

Kanilea Clips and Medallions are made with Sterling Silver, lending the pens a very classy, high-quality look.

All Kanilea pens come with a postcard featuring the photograph that inspired your pen’s design.

Takeaways and Where to Buy

In my 2018 recap, I wrote that I would be limiting the number of pens I bring into my collection going forward. One of those slots will almost certainly be held open for a Kanilea Pen, as they always seem to be releasing something new and interesting around the time of the D.C. Pen Show, where I’ve purchased both my Nui Nalu and my Hanauma Bay fountain pens. These are among my favorite fountain pens in my collection, due to both the overall aesthetic as well as the care and craftsmanship that go into the pens themselves, and I look forward to adding more in the future.

Kanilea doesn’t sell through retailers, only directly, so you are limited to purchasing one of their pens through the Kanilea Pen Company website or at a pen show. This year, Kanilea will be attending the Baltimore, Chicago, Washington, D.C., and San Francisco Pen Shows. If you can get to one of these shows, I personally recommend visiting the Kanilea table and seeing the pens in person before you make a decision. Don’t get me wrong, all of their pens are beautiful, but there is so much variation in the materials they use that one pen might speak to you more than others.

Disclaimer: I purchased the pens featured in this review with my own funds, for my own personal collection. I was not compensated in any way for this review, and all opinions expressed are my own.

I've been waiting for a couple of months now before publishing a review of what might be my favorite pen acquisition of the past year: the "Mauna Kea" by the Kanilea Pen Co. Kanilea is new to the scene, even if Hugh and Karol Scher, the proprietors, have been around the pen show circuit for years. Kanilea launched at last year's Washington D.C. Pen Show to much acclaim - certain models of their pens sold out immediately. Each piece in their lineup is inspired by a location or "element" in Hawaii, and is hand-turned from a custom acrylic reflecting the colors in pictures taken on family trips to the islands. Even though these pens aren't "custom" in the sense that they're designed to individual customer's specifications, every aspect of these pens has been custom-designed to the maker's specifications, and even the JoWo nib has been tuned to perfection. It's a unique product, and you're not going to find anything like it elsewhere. I don't give numbered "ratings" to reviews, but if I did I'd give the Kanilea Mauna Kea as close to a perfect score as any pen I've reviewed in the past two years.

Each Kanilea pen features a sterling silver or plated sterling silver medallion inset into the cap.

Design and Build

Hugh Scher turns each pen by hand, using custom acrylics made by Jonathan Brooks of the Carolina Pen Company. I don't own any of Jonathan's pens, but I can vouch for his ability as a material maker. Hugh's workmanship on the pens themselves is exceptional. With any handmade pen you should expect some degree of imperfections and inconsistency in each finished product - to a degree, that's what makes a hand-crafted pen unique - but I honestly haven't been able to find any such "flaws" on my Mauna Kea. The cap is centered, the threads are smooth, the edges rounded perfectly, and as I'll talk about a bit more later, the nib writes exceptionally well.

The depth of the material is what drew me to the Mauna Kea Model in the first place.

The depth of color and contrasting swirls of brown and white/ivory drew me to this particular model. As the name suggests, the pen is inspired by Mauna Kea, the volcano on Hawaii's "Big Island." Because the acrylic blanks are hand-poured, each Kanilea pen is unique in both color and pattern, even among the same model. In other words, my Mauna Kea has a different mix of browns, whites, and pearlescent swirls than any other Mauna Kea pen out there. When you visit Kanilea at a pen show, you'll have the opportunity to see this in person, handle the individual pens, and choose which one you like best.

The selection of Kanilea pens available at the Baltimore Pen Show, to hold and test out. (Less one Mauna Kea...)

Kanilea pens come in several different shapes, or "design profiles," but not all are available in every model. From speaking with Hugh at this year's Atlanta Pen Show, I learned that Kanilea makes each model in those profiles that best showcase the material. For example, the Mauna Kea is only available in the "Classic Flush" profile, a streamlined clipless design. Other models, such as the Pahoehoe, Nui Nalu, or Kilauea, are available in different profiles and have the option of adding a clip, which I might choose for my second Kanilea pen just to mix things up. If fountain pens aren't your thing, certain models of Kanilea pens are also available as ballpoints.

My Mauna Kea right after I purchased it, above the photograph that inspired the pen's design.

Nibs and Writing Experience

Kanilea pens use No. 6 JoWo nibs, in either polished stainless steel, two-toned gold-plated stainless steel, or 18k gold. JoWo nibs are fairly standard in the custom pen world, and most pen makers use nibs manufactured by either JoWo or Schmidt due to their reliability. JoWo nibs are also about as close as you can get to having a "universal nib unit," since most pens featuring JoWo nibs use standard screw-in nib unit, and a Kanilea nib unit, for example, should be interchangeable with a nib unit sold by Franklin-Christoph, Scriptorium, or Edison Pens.

I must say that the medium nib on my Mauna Kea is, hands down, the best JoWo nib I've ever written with (and I'm not the only one to say so.) Hugh works on each nib individually before handing over your new pen, and if you visit Kanilea at the pen show, you'll have the opportunity to have Hugh adjust it to your preference, in terms of ink flow, smoothness, etc. Kanilea carries a range of JoWo nib sizes, from extra fine (EF) all the way up to a 1.1mm stub nib.

The shape of the pen makes the Mauna Kea an excellent writing instrument for longer sessions. The cylindrical profile, with the barrel tapering slightly towards the back, balances the pen nicely, and the lightweight acrylic ensures your hand won't tire. The concave section offers a comfortable grip, and the threads are both high enough on the section and smooth enough so as not to dig into your hand. You can't post the cap, but this is a larger pen so you probably wouldn't want to anyway.

Takeaways and Where to Buy

If you're in the market for a unique piece to add to your collection, I highly recommend a pen from the Kanilea Pen Company. Kanilea doesn't sell through retailers (at least not yet), so you will need to purchase directly from them, either via their website or at one of the pen shows they attend. I'd highly recommend visiting them at either the upcoming DC Fountain Pen Supershow (August 3-6), or the San Francisco Pen Show (August 25-27).

It's not pictured here (because it's buried in my backyard) but the box comes wrapped in a biodegradable paper band with the Kanilea logo, which has wildflower seeds embedded in it!

Kanilea pens are not inexpensive, starting at $395, with gold nibs costing an additional $120. The price initially might seem high for an acrylic pen with a steel nib, but once you consider (1) the unique nature and cost of these particular custom acrylics; (2) the quality; (3) the fact that all Kanilea pens are entirely turned by hand; and (4) that all Kanilea pens feature a custom designed medallion crafted from sterling silver or 14K gold-plated sterling silver, the pricing makes sense. Each pen also comes with a "keepsake box" handmade from polished black walnut, which I keep on my desk and use as a pencil box. It's a high quality add-on, featuring a hidden hinge and a magnetic closure. I certainly feel that I got my money's worth.

Disclaimer: I purchased this pen with my own funds, for my own collection. I was not compensated in any way for this review.