Updating Prior Reviews: Platinum Curidas Feed Issues and the Diamine Music Set

May 28, 2020

In light of recent news surrounding what sounds like a design flaw with the Platinum Curidas, it’s appropriate for me to take a minute and update my recent review. For those who have not heard, there have been numerous reports of the feeds on the Curidas cracking, and apparently the problem is pervasive enough that Platinum has stopped shipping the pen to retailers while they figure things out. Brad provides a good update on Episode #411: Curious Case of the Curidas Cracking.

What about my Curidas pens? After learning of the issue with the feeds, I closely inspected both of my pens and was pleased to discover the feeds intact, with no signs of cracking. That was Monday morning. Yesterday morning (Wednesday), I checked again, and noticed that the feed on my red pen was split down the middle.

The cracked feed on my red Curidas (right), compared against the normal feed on my green Curidas.

So far, this has not caused any performance issues with the pen. It doesn’t leak, burp ink, hard-start, or show any symptoms that you might typically find in a fountain pen with a damaged feed. Will that change? Who knows. I plan to keep using this pen until it starts causing problems, and hope that Platinum comes up with a fix. I can only assume that some part of the mechanism is too tight, generating pressure on the feed and causing it to crack over time. While design issues are inevitable in a pen this complex, it surprises me that something this basic didn’t show up in Platinum’s prototypes, especially given how prevalent the cracking issue seems to be. It’s a shame, because otherwise I’m really starting to enjoy the Curidas as a daily writer. I’ve kept my two pens inked up since writing my review, and for my grip and writing style, it’s an extremely comfortable pen to use.

Meanwhile, on a Happier Note…

Diamine-Music-Set-Tchaikovsky-Chopin-Schubert

In March I reviewed inks from the Diamine Music Set, which contains 10 inks all “themed” around a different composer. At the time of my initial review, I had used two of the ten: Strauss and Vivaldi. I’ve since inked pens with three more, all of which are excellent. Tchaikovsky (a rich royal blue) and Chopin (a dark grey with blue undertones) easily could serve as daily drivers. Schubert (a darker teal green) has had less time in the pen, but I’m enjoying this color that I wouldn’t typically pick for myself. You can read my full review of the Music Set and see a full set of swabs here.

Pen Review: TWSBI ECO Yellow and ECO White Rose Gold

May 23, 2020

Last month, I wrote a piece about how TWSBI recently has made a major push to expand the ECO lineup, seemingly at the expense of the TWSBI 580, it’s “flagship” fountain pen. While I remain a die-hard fan of the 580, I also appreciate what the ECO brings to the table: a high-quality, high-capacity piston filling fountain pen with a reliable nib at roughly $31. And now, the TWSBI ECO is available in a wide range of colors and designs.

My two soft spots in this hobby are red and yellow pens, meaning that if a company releases a model I like in either of these two colors, I’ll likely buy it. So when TWSBI announced the ECO Yellow earlier this year, it was pretty much a foregone conclusion. Now that I have the pen in hand, I have no regrets. The bright yellow acrylic really pops, and the EF nib writes a smooth, wet line. I’ve not had much experience with TWSBI EF nibs in the past, and while this one pleasantly surprised me, it’s definitely a wider, “German” EF, and definitely not a needlepoint or Japanese-style nib.

The Rose Gold Eco is actually branded the “ECO RG,” thought I’ve not seen it referred to as such in marketing releases.

The more unique release, which sold so quickly it was out of stock at most retailers until recently, is the TWSBI ECO White Rose Gold. Years ago, TWSBI released a 580 fountain pen featuring rose gold trim, which, while extremely popular, was plagued by reports of the trim wearing off over time. I understand that TWSBI reformulated the rose gold plating not only to increase durability, but to offer a bit more shine and “rose” tone. Whatever they did, the end result looks great, especially paired with the white acrylic.

The rose gold nib is absolutely gorgeous.

For a full review of the ECO fountain pen, check out this post here. I won’t rehash the specifications, etc. in detail, but I continue to believe that the TWSBI ECO is a well-made, reliable fountain pen that represents outstanding value at its price point.

There’s no discernible difference in line width between the standard Eco steel nib and the rose gold plated nib. Both nibs write on the wider side for an extra-fine.

Takeaways and Where to Buy

TWSBI remains a brand to watch. The company has not only demonstrated its devotion to innovation and continual improvement as it tweaks its product lines in response to customer feedback, but it’s adherence to a reasonable pricing scheme has positioned the company to thrive in all sorts of market conditions, as fountain pen enthusiasts look for affordable ways to indulge in their favorite hobby. You can purchase both the TWSBI ECO Yellow and White Rose Gold and still spend well under $100.

You can currently purchase TWSBI ECO fountain pens in the T.G.S. Curated Shop, starting at $30.99 for the standard line, and $49.99 for the pens with rose gold trim. While some might balk at the premium for rose gold, which sees the pen approaching the cost of a standard TWSBI 580, keep in mind that a TWSBI 580 with rose gold trim actually costs $84.99.

Lamy Safari "Candy" Special Edition Part II: The Ballpoint

May 21, 2020

The Lamy Safari ballpoint gets little love or attention, and it’s not fair. At $16 retail, this pen is not only a must-have for the Lamy fan who needs a functional writer for “everyday” use, but it also makes a great gift for someone who appreciates fun writing instruments but may not necessarily be ready to dive into the world of fountain pens. Honestly, I’m a little embarrassed to be writing this review six years into this blog, having never owned, or even used, one of these pens until now.

The Lamy Safari ballpoint features the same triangular grip as the fountain pen, but it’s much more subtle and less pronounced.

This pen is nothing fancy - just a plastic retractable ballpoint that uses Lamy’s proprietary M16 refill. At one time, Lamy ballpoints had a reputation for being dry writers that failed to leave a solid, visible line on the page. (If you’ve ever written with a really cheap ballpoint pen that “skips,” you’ll know what I’m talking about.) In recent years, these refills have performed remarkably better, to the point where my Lamy Pico pocket ballpoint and Lamy 2000 ballpoint have become favorites. Based on how much I’ve been enjoying these Safaris, I suspect they will also find a regular spot on my desk.

The only durability question I have about this pen relates to the rubber knock. Does this rubber harden and crack over time? Has anyone used one of these pens long-term?

Takeaways and Where to Buy

Look, the Lamy Safari ballpoint pen doesn’t offer anything especially unique in terms of a writing experience, but at the $16 price point, you’re getting a solid writer with the Lamy aesthetic, and there’s not much risk to the purchase. Personally, I always get frustrated because ballpoint pens are either really narrow/skinny, making them uncomfortable to write with for long periods of time, or super chunky and inelegant. The Safari strikes a midpoint and is extremely comfortable to grip. Combined with the accessible price, that’s a major selling point.

I purchased these Lamy Safari ballpoint pens from Pen Chalet, as part of the same order where I picked up the recently reviewed Lamy Safari Special Edition “Candy” fountain pens. Lamy currently has the “Candy” ballpoints in stock, as well as the standard Safari ballpoints (which are, curiously, slightly more expensive than the special editions). As I mentioned above, these are relatively inexpensive purchases, so if you haven’t tried one, it’s a fun add-on to your next order.

Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. The Gentleman Stationer is a participant in the Pen Chalet affiliate program, which allows me to earn store credit from referrals and is one way I support the blog and acquire new products for review.

Lamy-2000-Stainless-Steel-Montblanc-149-Platinum-Curidas

More Stock Nibs That Offer Line Variation

May 17, 2020

One fountain pen rabbit hole that many people tumble down quickly is nib modification. The emergence of a new generation of nib grinder, nibmeisters, nib workers, nib technicians, whatever your preferred term, has formed a major part of the resurgence in fountain pens and fine writing accessories over the past few years. Having a nib ground makes for a great way to add more personality to your writing, and even a simple nib tuning can improve ink flow and performance on some pens that write “inconsistently” out of the box. While it’s great to have these services available, it can add anywhere from $20-80 to the cost of your pen, depending on what work you have done.

I’ve written before on “stock” stub nibs - that is, nibs available from the factory pre-ground or shaped into a stub italic, which adds line variation to your writing in the form of narrow cross-strokes and wider downstrokes. You can read more about these types of nibs, which are advertised as stubs, in this series of posts titled “Stock Stub Nibs: Exploring Specialty Nibs” and “Exploring Stock Stub Nibs, Part II: Higher-End Options.”

A close-up of the slightly squared off, “stubbish” broad nib on my Montblanc 149.

What I would like to write about today is a bit different: those nibs sold by pen companies as standard extra-fines, mediums, or broads, but which don’t write like a typical rounded nib. Here are a few of my own “secrets”:

Lamy Studio 14k Extra-Fine Nib. I have no idea whether other 14k Lamy “Z” nibs exhibit this characteristic, because they tend to be a bit too wet for me and I stick to the extra-fine, but I’ve noticed that this nib shows subtle architect-like qualities. “Architect” or “Hebrew Italic” nibs are essentially the reverse of your classic stub or italic, and show broad cross-strokes and narrow downstrokes. It’s a relatively expensive grind, so if you’d like a pen that writes with this style of line variation, especially one with a gold nib, the “premium” version of the Lamy Studio is an option that I can highly recommend.
Platinum Curidas Stainless Steel Medium Nib. One of the more pleasant surprises of 2020 (and there have been relatively few of them), was the medium stainless steel nib on Platinum’s new Curidas retractable fountain pen. Though I had to replace a scratchy, dry fine nib, the medium nib arrived with perfect ink flow and subtle, yet still stubbish, line variation.
Lamy 2000 Broad Nib. Sometimes described as a “shovel,” the 21k Lamy 2000 broad nib leaves a broad, wet line with definite stubbish characteristics. I’ve written many pieces on my love for the Lamy 2000 fountain pen (as well as the other versions) in the past, so I won’t repeat myself here.
Montblanc Broad, BB, and BBB Nibs. Many high-end pen companies such as Montblanc don’t offer a “stock” stub option, at least not in name. It can be scary to spends as much as $600-$1000 on a brand new Montblanc pen and send it off for nib work that automatically voids the warranty. Standard Montblanc broad, double-broad, and triple-broad nibs can be extremely stubbish to begin with, so if you want a stub, before you make an appointment with a nib grinder, consider ordering one of these stock nib sizes and trying it out unmodified first.

The fairly sharp, squared-off broad nib on my Lamy 2000 Stainless Steel model.

This particular Studio 14k nib isn’t the absolute best example, but you can still see the subtle architect-like shaping of the tipping material. Others I have in my collection might be slightly more pronounced.

Note the slightly broader cross-strokes on the writing sample from the Lamy Studio.

As you can see from these writing samples (all done on Baron Fig Mastermind paper, for reference), if you’re thinking of one of these nib modifications, consider trying stock nibs first. You may be pleasantly surprised. Of course, YMMV with each individual nib, and there is always the chance that you’ll get one that isn’t stubbish at all, or that writes a more or less pronounced line than the ones pictured here. It always helps to let the pen store know exactly what you’re looking for, especially with brands like Montblanc, and they try their best to pick out the best nib for your needs.

These are just examples that I pulled from pens in my own collection. I want to open this up for comments! Are there any other nibs you’re aware of that should be on this list?

Disclaimer: This post contains links to paid sponsors and affiliates.

Pen Review: Lamy Safari "Candy" Special Editions

May 14, 2020

Lamy remains one of my favorite all-around stationery brands, particularly for those of us who both use our pens on a daily basis, and appreciate the ability to dabble in the special and limited edition fun from time to time. While Lamy's implementation of its limited edition strategy has been hit and miss over the years, they regularly release some exceptional pens, and the 2020 Safari special editions are no exception.

I love Safari’s with coated clips, especially those that match the pen barrel.

For the second year in a row, Lamy chose to release not one, but three, special edition Safaris. Building on last year's "Pastels,” the company chose "Candy" as this year's theme, and released three pens in shades of purple ("Violet"), turquoise ("Aquamarine"), and yellow ("Mango"). Mango is my favorite, probably because the yellow-orange hue is completely different from anything Lamy has released in the past. While I love the standard yellow Safari, the matte texture and matching clip lend the Mango a warmth the yellow fountain pen lacks.

The three “Candy” Safaris on the left; the three 2019 “Pastel” editions on the right.

What will be curious to see going forward is whether Lamy continues the three-pen releases. Amid growing economic uncertainty for much of the world, will we see companies scale back the number of special and limited editions pens, and maybe even discontinue certain slower-selling items from their standard lines? Lamy tends to make fairly large runs of Safaris, and it's not unusual to see last year's special edition pens on sale a year (or more) later. For example, the 2019 "Pastel" special editions continue to be available for purchase. In the case of Lamy, however, I wouldn't be surprised if things stayed status quo (or if sales even increased) since the company's lower price point pens might actually see an uptick in demand as pen enthusiasts look for less costly ways to indulge in their hobby.

This time around I purchased the matching ballpoints for two of the pens:

The standard Lamy Safari in yellow, on the left, and in Mango (with matching ballpoint) on the right.

Takeaways and Where to Buy

This is a great Lamy Safari release. As a proud member of #teamsafari (as opposed to #teamalstar), I immediately sprung for all three pens to add to my collection of recent special editions. In my opinion, the Mango pen in particular has the potential to be one of the better Safari's Lamy has made.

A combination of high demand and Covid-19 related shipping issues delayed the initial launch of the Candy Safaris, but most Lamy retailers now have them available for purchase. I purchased the pens featured in this review from site sponsor Pen Chalet, which currently has all three fountain pens available, in addition to the rollerball and ballpoint versions. The fountain pen is priced at just under $30, the rollerball $20, and the ballpoint $16. I'm something of a latecomer to the Safari ballpoint, and plan on reviewing that pen separately soon. If you’re interested in picking up one of the Pastel fountain pens, Pen Chalet is currently offering a free converter with purchase.

Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. I am a participant in the Pen Chalet affiliate program, which allows me to earn store credit that I can use to acquire items for review on the blog, like the pens featured here.