It's time to pick a new notebook! This weekend I finished a personal journal (an Atelier Musubi bank paper A5, bound in soft fabric), and while I enjoyed my time with it, I was ready to move on. The Musubi Journal itself was an exceptionally well made book: The binding and cover held up well over the course of nearly two years, despite a fair amount of travel in my briefcase alongside laptops, pen cases, scissors, sharpened pencils, and who-knows-what-else. And while I find bank paper quite ink friendly, it's never been my favorite paper for everyday writing. Hand oil can cause problems with skipping and feathering on the lower half of a page, and for my personal journal, I don't want to worry about always having blotting paper or a calligraphy smudge-guard handy. So the next choice for an everyday notebook/journal was always going to be something more no-nonsense.
Whenever I choose a new notebook, planner, or journal, I run the risk of paralysis-by-analysis. As expected, I found myself overthinking this decision, so (late) last night as I was leaving I walked out of my office into the main shop area and pulled a Maruman Mnemosyne A5 Hardcover journal in mint green off the shelf. I've been excited about these Mnemosyne journals since I first saw them at last year's NY Now and have been looking for a way to get one into the rotation. (We won't talk about how long it actually took Maruman to get these things to the U.S. market.)
I love a good pre-printed Table of Contents. Especially one that is long enough to use as a true index. Which you will need on a 250-page notebook.
So why did I choose this notebook?
Reliability. Mnemosyne paper works well with all inks + pencil, with decent dry times, no feathering, and very little bleedthrough. The paper in the journal is a step up, at 90gsm instead of the typical 80gsm in the Mnemosyne spirals and the 70gsm in the Maruman Basic notebooks. While I don't really push paper all that much in notebooks that I use as personal journals - I’m writing, not testing inks - I've had no issues with any fountain pens that I've used in my first few days of writing.
It's "Just a Notebook." The Mnemosyne journal looks nice, but at the end of the day it will appear, to the non-stationery-addict eye, indistinguishable from your typical Moleskine, Leuchtturm, Anecdote, Endless, or other similar A5 hardcover with an elastic closure. The fact that I have a dozen just like it sitting outside the door to my office and a few more in my personal stash removes the block you sometimes feel when you have a really nice notebook that you’re hesitant to use because you don’t want to mess it up.
Table of Contents. In the Musubi, I made the rookie mistake of not reserving pages for an index or table of contents. The Mnemosyne does that for me, with a four-page table of contents that allows for 21 entries on each page. Whenever I finish a notebook, I go back and flip through to highlight pages with ideas I want to remember and possibly develop further elsewhere. The table of contents will let me do that in real time as I work through the notebook, or during my close-out review after I finish. The pages are also pre-numbered for easy reference.
Open Layout with Lots of Paper. This notebook contains 239 numbered pages (including the TOC) - a lot of paper for a journal in this style. The ruling is a .5mm dot grid. For bullet journalers and those who like to create their own charts and layouts, Maruman has included markers in the margins that you can use as guides. I probably won't use this particular notebook as a bullet journal or other homemade planner, but the functionality is there. You also have two ribbon bookmarks and the standard kraft paper envelope attached to the back cover.
Takeaways and Where to Buy
I'm only a couple of days in, but so far this Mnemosyne journal is exactly what I needed, and importantly, exactly what I expected from Maruman in terms of no-nonsense quality and functionality. If you're looking for a hardbound dot grid notebook in the classic A5+elastic style, this version is fountain pen foolproof and should last you for the bulk of the year, depending on whether you're a daily journaler and how much you write each day.
Available from most Maruman retailers, including our own shop, the Mnemosyne Hardcover Journal comes in black, navy blue, grey, and mint, and is currently priced at $39. While the price would seem higher than similar notebooks, this notebook has a noticeably higher page count (240 pages vs. the usual 190-200), and of course you get the Mnemosyne quality. The most remarkable aspect of this entire release is Maruman's decision to release Mnemosyne products in colors other than black. For me, the mint is clearly the winner, and I'd love to see a darker green, like they used in the Kleid x Mnemosyne collaboration. The newer A5 flex cover notebooks included a white version, but I could see that getting pretty dirty over the course of a year.
Come see us in-store! As noted above, we have the journals shown here, the rest of the Mnemosyne lineup, and more. Note that we have special hours on July 3rd and 4th. Saturday hours of operation will be per the usual 10am-6pm.
The Mnemosyne (bottom) is a thick notebook with lots of paper!
