Pen Review: Sailor Professional Gear Imperial Black Edition

One of my personal favorites, that until recently was always inked and used on a daily basis,  is the Sailor Professional Gear Imperial Black Edition.  Following a close call (and near total tragedy), my Imperial Black recently rejoined the rest of my collection thanks to Mr. Mike Masuyama, but more on that later.  

Aesthetically, this is one of the most beautiful pens that I own.  Sailor nailed it on the design.  I love the flat top cap and base, and the dark trim sets off the matte black color. 

I won this pen approximately a year ago in an eBay auction held by a Japanese eBay seller, and by sacrificing quick shipping and the U.S. display box option, I saved a little bit of money.  This pen has special meaning to me because I received it in the mail the day my daughter was born, and was carrying it and using it (with permanent Kiwa Guro pigmented ink, of course) to sign paperwork our entire first weekend with her.  Thus, you have my answer to that eternal question:  What pen would you use to sign your child's birth certificate?  (For me, it's not the Visionnaire.  I will give Morgan and his team credit, though.  They nailed the packaging on their product, as opposed to the hideous faux crushed velvet brown box in which this pen arrived.)  

If Elvis had purchased a pen in 1973 (which I'm sure he did), it probably would have come in a box like this. 

All joking aside, I knew from the eBay listing that this product was not coming to me in its original packaging (in order to save on shipping), so needless to say I wasn't expecting much in that regard.  This was my first Sailor pen, and what I was looking for here was one of Sailor's excellent nibs in a matte black pen with dark trim.  Apparently, Sailor uses Titanium ion plating to darken their trim, as opposed to Ruthenium.  Either way, I like the way this pen looks.  

Close-up of the titanium ionized trim.  My completely non-scientific survey of the pen industry revealed that Ruthenium is more commonly used in "stealth trim" than other metals, so Sailor's process may be unique?  Don't take my word for it--it's entirely speculation, and it doesn't really matter.  Both look great. 

I opted for the fine nib, which is equivalent to a western extra fine or narrower.  Despite the fact that it is 21k gold, the nib is not "soft."  In fact, it's a fairly stiff nib that lays a very fine line.  For example, the Sailor "fine" lays down a line of ink approximately one-half the width of my Pelikan M600 with an extra fine nib.  This is perfect for my needs, since I spend the majority of time at my day job editing others' written work product and scrawling marginalia.

A writing sample is included below.  The ink used is Sailor's Kiwa Guro nano-black.  As you can see from the photos, I'm working up a review of that as well. 

Nib Close-Up.  The tip is so fine that I had a hard time getting my camera to focus on it.  My photography skills need work.  Anyway, take a look at the classy scrollwork on the nib.  Tastefully done, in my opinion, with Sailor's iconic anchor symbol.   

Close-up image of the writing:  Note the very tight lines.  Paper is Field Notes Shelterwood edition.

The Good

  • Sailor nibs are amazing.  Although I had the nib tweaked to perfection by Mike Masuyama (who I believe used to work for Sailor), the nib wrote extremely well out of the box and I used it for several months before having it slightly tuned at the D.C. Pen Show.

  • Weight:  The pen is very light and fits nicely in the hand.  You can use this pen for long writing sessions without your hand becoming tired. 

  • Looks:  I love Matte black "stealth" pens, even though they are on the verge of becoming played out with every pen company trying to bring out a stealth model. 

The Cons:

  • Weight:  The pen is very light and can fly out of your hand if it becomes sweaty.  As I alluded to above, this happened to me once, and a slight drop of four inches onto my desk bent the 21K nib nearly in half.  Regardless of how stiff the nib writes, 21K gold is a soft material, and bends easily.  I managed to straighten it somewhat myself, but I had to send it to Mike Masuyama to restore the ink flow to a proper level.  Of course, it's now as good as new, but I'm much more careful with this pen.  

  • Size:  If you don't post your pens, the Sailor Pro Gear model might be too small for you.  I have to post this pen in order for it to write comfortably, but I post nearly every pen I own and don't have a problem with doing so. 

  • Sailor pens take proprietary cartridges and a proprietary converter.  It is what it is. 

The Overall Verdict.  this is one of the best, if not the best, writing pens in my collection.  The nib is superb.  That the pen also looks great is a bonus.  It's hardly ever out of rotation, and even then it's only to make sure that other pens in my collection get regular use. There are multiple buying options for this pen, and as I mentioned in the review I purchased directly from a Japanese seller, since for whatever reason Sailor has elected to price this pen at nearly double the Japanese price in the U.S. market.

July EDC Update

When I got home last weekend, I switched up the pen and ink rotation.  I've been using these since, and will probably use most of them for another week or two before I get the itch to update. 

Pens from left:  (1) Omas Ogiva in Saft Green with Masuyama-ground medium nib, loaded with Iroshizuku Kon Peki (2) Nakaya portable writer with medium nib, loaded with Montblanc Alfred Hitchcock; (3) Lamy 2000 with Greg Minuskin retipped .9mm stub nib, loaded with Akkerman Voorhout Violet; (4) Parker Sonnet Cisele with Fine Nib, loaded with Aurora Black; and (5) Waterman Phileas with Medium Nib, loaded with Iroshizuku Yama Budo.

Of this loadout, my favorite combos have been the Parker Sonnet with the Aurora Black (a classic pairing, IMHO), and the Nakaya with the Montblanc Hitchcock (the only ink I've hoarded).  I haven't spent a lot of time with the Omas yet, but that's primarily due to the fact that it's a wet writer and most of my work this week has been done on cheapo paper that feathers and bleeds like crazy.  I'm also really starting to love the Phileas, which I recently received in a trade.  Finally, Greg Minuskin did some masterful work retipping this Lamy 2000, which had been ruined by nib work so bad that even Mike Masuyama couldn't salvage it.  Reviews of all will be up at some point.  Enjoy the weekend everyone!  

Pen Review: Kaweco Liliput

The Liliput is one of those pens that doesn't get as much attention as its slightly larger pocket pen brethren, the Kaweco Sport Series.  I understand why--the pen is very small, and is a "pocket pen" in the truest sense of the word.  While the Sport and the AL Sport both post in a way that makes them almost full size, the Liliput remains, well, liliputian.  This pen probably appeals to a smaller group of users than the rest of Kaweco's offerings:  those people who absolutely must carry a fountain pen with them everywhere they go.  

As you can see, the pen is small, but not so small as to render it unusable.  I like this pen a lot, and use it regularly as a pocket carry. 

The pen certainly is not so small as to render it unusable.  I use this pen a lot, particularly as a pocket carry when I'm out and about.  With the right ink, it's a good Field Notes/pocket notebook pen because it slides into your pocket easily and the EF nib that I have is not so wet that the ink bleeds through the page significantly.  I can still write on both sides.

Other reviewers have found the pen too light.  The version I have is the black aluminum version, and true, there isn't much weight to it.  BUT, Kaweco now offers a brass version available from Jetpens.com here in a new "Wave" styling.  Brad at the Pen Addict has reviewed this pen and likes it a lot.  (Link Here)  If you're concerned about the weight of the pen, and would like a pen with more heft, consider the brass version.

It goes without saying that this pen is cartridge-fill only.  The much-maligned Kaweco mini-converter might fit, but I would not recommend it.  Instead, pick up some cartridges of Kaweco's great ink, and refill those with a syringe.    

The Liliput is ultraportable.  See here compared to the Kaweco AL Sport.

If I had to choose one "negative" to discuss, I would raise an issue with the nib that I chose.  The tines of my EF nib are cut unevenly, which you can see in the picture below.  This causes the pen to write with slightly more tooth than I would otherwise prefer and to dig into the paper if I catch a wrong angle.  I've not seen the same issue with the Kaweco Medium I own, or the fine or broad nibs that I've tried.  In the future on Kaweco pens, I would probably stick to the absolute basics (F,M,B).    

Overall, the verdict on this pen is positive.  For a pocket pen, It's a definite "recommend," but it's important to keep the "pocket pen" part in mind.  This pen was not designed to take 20 pages of longhand notes in a sitting or write a novel.  I'm glad to have it as part of my Kaweco collection.  

The nib slit looks unevenly cut on this pen.  I'll probably purchase a new nib eventually, and switch to the smoother writing fine or medium.  Kaweco nibs are interchangeable, at least for the Sport and Liliput models. 

Scan of handwritten review in Kaweco Ruby Red, and ink I've grown to love but a discussion of which is outside the scope of this review.

Scan of handwritten review in Kaweco Ruby Red, and ink I've grown to love but a discussion of which is outside the scope of this review.

PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT:  To all of those who participated in my giveaway last week, check the comments of that post to see if you've won!  I've only heard from two of my four winners and if I don't hear from the other two by Sunday I'm going to have to pick two new ones. 

Ink Review: Pelikan Edelstein Turmaline (2012 Ink of the Year)

I'm back.  And after taking a bit of time to sort through my ink sample drawer (after reading this scary FPN post), I decided to ink up a few samples for review.  (This one ended up being for review only, because it turns out it was not a fave.)  The ink in question is Pelikan Edelstein Turmaline, which is Pelikan's 2012 "Ink of the Year" for their Edelstein line, which, to my knowledge, means that the ink is produced for one year only and then it goes out of production.  They must produce a ton of ink during that one year, however, because both Turmaline and Amber (the 2013 Ink of the Year) are still in stock at retailers like Anderson Pens (links here and here).

In truth, I have not tried many of the Edelstein Inks.  I hear great things about the Topaz and Tanzanite colors, and mixed reviews on the others.  For one thing, the ink is somewhat expensive at approximately $23 for 50ml, although this price point is sadly becoming more the rule than the exception (Thanks Sailor!).  Another issue I have is that the ink is fairly dry, a characteristic of Pelikan ink in general.  I write with a lot of extra fine nibs and stubs, and I prefer a relatively wet writing pen, so drier inks are not as enjoyable to me as others because they tend to be scratchy.  That said, I used a Waterman medium nib here, and Edelstein Turmaline had fairly good flow and dried very quickly on the page (about 3 seconds).  So why was this ink not a winner for me?

Two reasons:  (1) the color; and (2) the twenty minutes it took me to flush this ink out of my pen.  With regard to the color:  I would characterize this ink as a fuschia.  Some call it pink, but to my eyes it has a slight purple tinge to it, although it is very bright (almost neon).  Compare with Iroshizuku Yama-Budo below.  I much prefer the Yama-Budo, which I think has greater depth and is a much richer color, without sacrificing any positive attributes such as good dry time, etc.  With regard to cleaning, I used this pen in my new (review forthcoming) Waterman Phileas, and it took approximately 15 flushes with a bulb syringe (three with J.B.'s perfect pen flush) to get the water to stop running pink.  I actually filled the pen with Yama Budo afterwards because I was tired of trying to clean this ink out and the Yama Budo would mask any residual pink.  Anyway, some may love this color, and I wouldn't rule out Edelstein Ink in the future, but it's not for me.

I didn't notice until I posted this picture that when you view these two inks side by side, the Yama-Budo appears much more crimson.  I think this highlights how much "pinker" the Turmaline is. 

Vacation Planning

And so, when it comes to deciding what pens and paper to take on my upcoming weeklong vacation, I--as do all pen enthusiasts--face some difficult choices.  Fountain pens or non-fountain pens?  Bottled ink or cartridges?  Unfortunately, this may turn into a "working vacation," so I can't exactly go penless.  Paper will most likely be Field Notes.  As I mentioned earlier, I'm on the cusp of finishing my last Doane Utility Journal, which will happen before I leave on my trip, so I've got my Shelterwood and a fresh Field Notes Kraft edition ready to go.  So what else to take?  Since this is a road trip, there's no need to worry about the "airplane" factor. 

Sailor Pro Gear Imperial Black Edition with Sailor Kiwa Guro Nano Black Ink

Kiwa Guro and Pro Gear Imperial Black:  This pen and ink combo were made for each other, IMHO. 

Probably my all-time favorite pen and ink combination for pocket notebooks and Moleskines.  As Brad on the Pen Addict noted during his most recent podcast, which I was listening to driving home last night, Sailor's Nano-Black ink is incredibly dark and well-behaved, keeping a very clean line.  It is a pigmented ink, meaning that it contains superfine particles of pigment that theoretically could cause a clog, if you don't practice good pen hygiene.  Personally, I have never had a problem with this ink, except for possibly having a minor stroke when I got to the register and realized what it cost.  At close to $30 a bottle, it had better be good, but two years later I'm glad I made the investment.  Because the pigment sits on the paper and dries quickly, there is no feathering or bleedthrough on Field Notes or any other pocket notebook I have tried.  The only paper I could remotely get this ink to bleed on was a cheap Tops yellow legal pad, which frankly was useless with anything other than a pencil. 

So, for a one-week trip where I can bring one or two pens that I'm sure will write on basically anything, this combination makes the cut. 

Other Possibilities

Kaweco Sport with Kaweco Green Ink:  I've had this pen inked up for a week or so but have not had a chance to use it much.  I typically use my Kawecos when I'm on the road, so I'll probably take this one with me.

Karas Kustoms Render K:  As Ed Jelley observed, another great Field Notes pen.

This has turned into kind of a random post, but I'm excited to go on vacation, so there.  What are your favorite travel combos?

Note:  Because I will be on vacation starting this Friday, and I have no idea what my internet situation will be, posting may be spotty.  I intend to keep to my regular schedule if at all possible.