Fountain Pen Hospital is the last dedicated fountain pen store in New York City, located in the Financial District.

NYC Stationery Tour 2016

November 5, 2016

I don't have a review or anything for you all this weekend, but if you've been following along on Instagram, you'll know I've been posting some photos of my trip to New York City, including the various - and all too brief - stationery shopping stops I've made around town. Today is my "free day," so I'll have more time to explore. Stay tuned. I should have some good stuff to show off later this week.

Kinokuniya Bookstore has the full array of Midori Travelers Notebooks and refills.

And, of course, I stopped by C.W. Pencil Enterprise on the Lower East Side.  This is an older picture. Unfortunately I couldn't take a new one because their outside storefront is under construction. — And, of course, I stopped by C.W. Pencil Enterprise on the Lower East Side. This is an older picture. Unfortunately I couldn't take a new one because their outside storefront is under construction.

A view of the Freedom Tower from outside my hotel in Battery Park City

For further reading, please check out my Top 5 Stationery Stores in New York City post from last year. If I run across anything new, I will be updating this list in the coming weeks.

The Diplomat Aero (left) compared against the Esteem (right)

Pen Review: Diplomat Esteem

November 2, 2016

While I'm on a Diplomat kick, I figured that in addition to the higher-end Diplomat Aero, I would go ahead and post a quick review of one of Diplomat's mid-tier offerings, the Esteem. The Esteem isn't stocked by many retailers in the United States, probably because it sits in the difficult $50-$75 price range. Though there aren't many pens at that price point for it to compete with, I'm not sure that the Esteem presents a compelling enough offering to warrant purchasing this pen over, say, an imported Pilot Custom Heritage 92, a Platinum 3776, or even a TWSBI 580.

The Diplomat Lineup

Before I get into the Esteem itself, it may be helpful to explain Diplomat's lineup a bit, especially since this is a brand few are familiar with (at least in the States). Diplomat's high-end pens are the Excellence and the Aero, both of which have gold-nib options. The mid-tier options include the Balance, the Esteem, the Optimist, and the Traveller. There isn't really an "entry-level" diplomat pen that you see regularly priced below $50, though occasionally you can find the Esteem on sale. Curiously, Diplomat seems to have done very little to promote its various models other than the Aero, or to differentiate between its other offerings.

Build/Construction

The Esteem is a lighter - and, yes, cheaper feeling - pen than the Aero.

As befits it's lower price point, the construction on the Diplomat Esteem feels less sturdy than the build on the Aero. A few things make me waffle a bit when deciding whether or not I like this pen: First of all, while the barrel is metal (either anodized brass or aluminum?), the grip section is plastic. This pen reminds me somewhat of the Retro 51 fountain pen, at a slightly higher price point.

The clip on the Esteem also isn't as solid as the clip on the Aero; it's made from folded over steel.

Diplomat has done a nice job with the end-cap and finial on the Esteem. The back of the pen features a plain stainless end-cap, which helps the cap post nicely. The finial on the cap contains a "jewel" with Diplomat's propeller logo.

Diplomat's "Propeller" Logo is incorporated into the design on most of their pens. Here, it's featured on the cap finial of the Esteem.

Nib and Writing Experience

While my experience with the Diplomat Esteem's nib wasn't quite as good as my experience with the Diplomat Aero, the fine nib on my Diplomat Esteem is still pretty darn good, if a touch dry. As I've noticed with JoWo nibs in the past, there's not much difference in terms of line width between the fine and the medium. If I had to make a recommendation, I would go with the medium, which is a much smoother writer. The nib on my Aero is one of the smoothest-writing pens in my collection.

The Esteem shares the same stainless steel nib as the Aero, but the plastic section...I'm not really a fan.

Takeaways/Where to Buy

It's probably unfair for me to compare this pen to the Aero, because I like the former pen so much, and - to be frank - the Aero is intended to be a nicer, and more expensive, pen. That said, I personally would probably recommend saving a bit more money and holding out for the Aero rather than purchasing the Esteem. However, if you dislike the Aero's design, or prefer a pen with a more classic design, the Esteem may end up being a better entry point into the Diplomat brand.

The Diplomat Esteem is a bit harder to find at retail that the Diplomat Aero, which has become one of Diplomat's premium "flagship" pens. As with the Aero, the MSRP on this pen is too high, at $95. Street price tends to be in the $50-75, which is more reasonable, and Amazon again has the best prices on Diplomat pens. Occasionally, you will find the Diplomat Esteem on Massdrop at a discount, typically in the sub-$50 range.

Disclaimer: Massdrop provided me with this pen through their affiliate/referral program at no charge.

Pen Review: Diplomat Aero

October 29, 2016

The biggest surprise from my 2016 D.C. Pen Show Haul was one of the lesser-known pens that I picked up: the Diplomat Aero. Diplomat is not as well-known in the States as other major German brands like Pelikan, Montblanc, Lamy, and Faber-Castell but they are building a small and loyal following, moreso than other smaller German manufacturers such as Otto Hutt and Cleo-Skribent. Let's just say there's a reason that they've been around since 1922. I've had the opportunity to write with multiple pens in Diplomat's lineup, and have been uniformly impressed, especially with the quality of the nibs. Along with the Otto Hutt Design 06, the Diplomat Aero has recently been one of my daily workhorses.

Unique Design and Quality Build

The "ribbed" design of the Diplomat Aero is its most distinctive visual feature.

The Aero sports one of the most unique fountain pen designs out there right now. (Well, there might be designs that are more "unique," but I'm referring to designs that are both unique and don't destroy the functionality of the pen.) It's inspired by the "Zeppelin" airships of the 1920s-1930s. The Company's "propeller" logo is painted on the top of the cap - more on that below. Overall, I enjoy the design. At first glance, some might consider this pen a little weird looking and even ostentatious, but in real life the design ends up being fairly understated, especially in the matte-black/gunmetal color scheme.

I enjoy using this pen posted more than unposted. The Aero is manufactured from relatively lightweight aluminum, so the fact that the pen is metal doesn't really affect the overall balance or make it awkward to use.

The Aero's aluminum construction gives it some heft, but this is a well-designed and well-balanced pen. Personally, I think this pen has better balance posted rather than unposted, but that's my preference with most pens as long as they aren't too long. The slip cap fits tightly, with no wiggle or play. It also posts firmly on the tapered end. The anodized section is grippy, slightly tapered, and makes the Aero a comfortable pen to use for long periods of time.

Those who don't like to post their pens will still be able to use the Aero just fine.

The clip has what I consider to be the optimal level of tension. It's not so loose that it feels flimsy, but it's not so tight that it won't easily clip to a shirt pocket. The matte black anodization on the clip makes it slide even easier.

I was able to easily scrape the Diplomat "propeller" logo off the top of the cap using a fingernail. Fortunately I like the look of the unadorned cap better.

The one issue I have with this pen has to do with the finish. Not necessarily the anodized coating that's applied to the metal body, clip, and section - which has held up very well - but with the painted Diplomat logo on the top of the cap. Mine started to flake off almost immediately, and I finally got so fed up with it that I took my fingernail to it and was able to completely remove it in less than 10 seconds. Honestly, this isn't a big deal for me because I like the plain black cap better than adorned version, but at this price point Diplomat needs to either fix this issue by actually etching the logo into the anodized coating or remove it from the top of the cap entirely. Flaking paint makes an otherwise excellent pen look cheap.

An Extremely Smooth JoWo Nib

As fun as the design is, the nib is what makes this pen a joy to use. My Aero sports a very smooth and very wet JoWo medium. This nib might be slightly wider than optimal for my style of writing, but for a stainless steel nib, it's been tuned perfectly. I met the Diplomat distributor at the D.C. Pen show, who told me that Diplomat has employees in the JoWo factory who personally test and tune all Diplomat nibs before they leave. I tend to believe this, because of the two Diplomat pens I own - the Aero and the lower-priced Diplomat Esteem - both write much better than stock JoWo nibs that I've purchased from other sources. These nibs clearly have been tuned.

Diplomat uses a standard cartridge/converter filling system. Nothing too exciting here.

Takeaways and Where to Buy

I like this pen and don't regret adding it to my rotation. While the flaking paint issue is annoying, the nib is outstanding and I love the design and the matte black color scheme. (If it's all-black or red, I'll typically buy it.)

Diplomat is popping up in multiple online retailers as the brand gains popularity. MSRP on the Diplomat Aero is $195, with some dealers selling for around $160, which is what I paid purchasing from the distributor directly at the D.C. Pen Show. While I really enjoy the pen, $160 is high, and $195 prohibitively expensive, especially compared to a similarly priced pen like the Otto Hutt 06 that didn't have the annoying flaking paint issue.

Fortunately, you can usually find the Aero on Amazon at a more reasonable price (though the actual price changes regularly). Massdrop deals on this pen also pop up from time to time. In addition to the matte black model featured in this review, the Aero comes in a silver version and a very attractive brown. (Honestly, I eventually may pick up a brown version for myself. The color looks that good.)

The Slice Planner (on Kickstarter Now!)

October 26, 2016

Kickstarters upon Kickstarters, that seems to be the theme for this month! Out of all the projects that I've had the opportunity to review, however, the Slice Planner has been the first where I've seen the project and thought, "I have a clear use case for that and I can't find it anywhere else on the market."

The Slice Planner claims to be "built around [the] core concept of easy synchronization between your paper notebooks and all your digital calendars, whether you use Outlook, Google, or Apple." It looks to accomplish this by combining a high-quality notebook with an app that makes it easy to scan handwritten entries into your digital calendar. Other companies have attempted similar "digital notebooks" in the past, with middling success. The most well known has been Moleskine, which sells an Evernote-integrated notebook and a "smart writing" pen/notebook set, which appears to have since been integrated on some level with the Livescribe 3 Smartpen. Slice Planner looks to take this idea a step further by offering reliable calendar integration.

So why does this project interest me? Recently, I've been looking for a notebook which can serve as a kind of "work journal," keeping track of how much time I spend on the various projects I have going on at any given time (including both the day job and the blog). The Slice Planner struck me as a good candidate. More than one week in, I'm very happy with how things have worked out, and can see myself using this notebook in this role going forward, regardless of how the app turns out.

The Notebook and "Clockface"

Photo courtesy of Slice Planner. This shows both the clothbound and leather versions, and also provides a fairly good indication of the size (approximately A5).

Before I even get into any of the "techy" features, or how the Slice Planner fares with its stated goal of "bridging the physical and digital divide," I want to say this: the Slice Planner is a great notebook, and the notebook itself is enough for me to back this Kickstarter, even if I never end up using the bundled app.

The notebook measures 5.5 x 8 inches, is clothbound, and contains two ribbon bookmarks and the omnipresent elastic strap to hold the book closed. The book itself seems very well made, and has held up well to my daily use. It's ever-so-slightly larger than a Baron Fig Confidant, but sports a similar cloth binding and lay-flat design.

The Slice Planner compared against the Baron Fig Confidant (top). The Slice Planner is slightly larger than the Confidant.

The inside of the Slice Planner features an undated, two-page-per-day layout. I love undated planners and notebooks, which avoid wasting paper on days when there isn't much to "plan" (such as days off, vacations, holidays, etc.). The left-hand page contains a "clockface" diagram which tracks 12 consecutive hours of time. You determine where on the diagram you want your day to "begin", and go from there. The right-hand page contains blank dot-grid paper for notes, diagrams, drawings, whatever.

Many people have noted the visual similarity to the Chronodex, by Patrick Ng. While the Slice Planner certainly borrows from the Chronodex, in the sense that both use the "clock face" circular layout, it's not an exact copy. For one thing, the Slice Planner tracks only 12 hours of time, whereas the Chronodex is designed to track up to 18. The folks at Slice Planner explain this based on a survey showing that, on average, most people do not plan more than 9.5 hours a day. Personally, I find the simplified Slice Planner diagram easier to use than the Chronodex, which never stuck with me. Since I don't use the Slice Planner as my primary calendar, the 12-hour limitation isn't an issue for me.

Yes, the Paper Is Reasonably Fountain Pen Friendly

Per the Kickstarter project page, the notebook contains "224 pages of acid-free premium Swedish paper for sketching and writing." I'll go ahead and get this out of the way first, because I know it's what everyone wants to know: Yes, it works fine with fountain pens. I experienced no bleed-through using any fountain pen I tried, which were limited to extra-fine, fine, and medium nibs. The only pen I used that exhibited some bleed-through/show-through was the Baron Fig Squire rollerball refill (which is the same as the Schmidt rollerball refill that ships with Retro 51 pens). Lamy Copper-Orange ink didn't work great (feathered a bit), but the the flip side of the page was still usable. I never tried to push this paper with especially wet nibs, but I imagine that you might see some feathering and bleeding with double broad nibs and stubs.

Testing various inks in my Slice Planner. You can see some show through from the following day, but no actual bleed.

Some have compared the paper to Baron Fig, but it reminds me more of Fabriano paper. The two are similar, but I've found Fabriano to be slightly more fountain pen friendly.

The App

And, finally, we get to the digital-analog integration aspect of this project. The project page makes it pretty clear that the Slice Planner app is NOT intended to replace your regular digital calendar, but rather to complement it by providing users with extra flexibility and making it more convenient to import things like appointments and notes into your phone or tablet.

The build of the Slice Planner app that was made available to me had limited functionality, but if it works as promised, I could see how I would use it occasionally. My day is often hyperscheduled with conference calls, appointments, hearings, etc., and needs to be broken down into time increments smaller than what I suspect the Slice Planner would be able to handle. I do plan to give the fully functional app a chance once it is released, and I'm excited to test the accuracy of the handwriting recognition feature.

That said, I'm not entirely convinced that opening a third-party app, waiting for it to access the camera, scanning in the information, correcting any handwriting recognition errors, and verifying that the entry is correctly reflected in your calendar app of choice ends up being more efficient than simply opening Fantastical or Omnifocus (two absolutely awesome apps that I use to manage my life) and entering an appointment/task manually or via Siri or Google Assistant. I'm pretty quick with my phone. That said, I'm excited to see developers and companies acknowledging that people still use paper planners and notebooks, and trying very hard to come up with thoughtful ways to accommodate these preferences. The Slice Planner app/calendaring system may end up working very well for some people; given my specific needs, it will require a lot more testing before I know whether it's something I can incorporate into the rotation.

Should You Back It?

UPDATE: The Slice Planner was a successful Kickstarter, and is now available for purchase via Amazon.

I backed the Slice Planner immediately, simply because I want two more of these notebooks. As discussed above, I probably won't use this as a classic planner, but more as a journal/notebook for tracking time management and work progress. While the App could be a nice bonus, it's not what's driving my decision to support this project.

You can back the Slice Planner by visiting their Kickstarter project page. The project is almost fully funded with 30 days to go, and rewards are still available for December delivery. Clothbound and leatherbound notebooks are available; the leatherbound notebooks accept a refill which Slice Planner will be selling aftermarket.

Disclaimer: I was provided with a prototype Slice Planner for review purposes, free of charge. I was not otherwise compensated in any way for this review, and the funds that I used to back the project are my own. This post contains affiliate links.

Pen Review: Trilogy Zero (On Kickstarter Now!)

October 22, 2016

Last week, I posted a brief announcement for the Trilogy Zero Minimalist Fountain Pen, which is now live on Kickstarter. Before I get into the details of this pen review, I should say that the pen Trilogy sent me for review is a prototype, NOT a final product. Trilogy was very insistent that the prototype had certain flaws that they plainly identified to me before sending me the pen, and which will be corrected before the final Kickstarter products ship to buyers.

That said, I like the Trilogy Zero overall, and I came away from the review impressed. This pen is not for everyone, but most machined metal pens aren't. Let's take a look in a bit more detail.

The Trilogy Zero features a smooth section and a black PVC-coated Bock Nib.

What I Liked about the Trilogy Zero

Size and Comfort. As other reviewers have observed, the Zero is larger in real life than it appears in the pictures, or at least it ended up being much larger than I expected. The added length balances the pen well for writing, especially since the cap doesn't post. The section is rather large, without a pronounced step down from the rest of the barrel, so you should be able to get a comfortable grip no matter how you hold your pen.
Presentation. The packaging is sleek and well-made. I like the concept of the wood box/pen rest that ships with the Zero, but wish that they had spent a bit more time on the finish. More on that from Mike Dudek. With a bit of polishing, the wood box might make an excellent piece for your desk.
Flat Ends. The Trilogy is completely flat on both ends, creating a tapered cylinder that will stand up vertically on your desk. I've done this at work and at home, and haven't had it fall over yet. The Zero's design reminds me of a more slender, tapered Newton Shinobi.
Nib. Trilogy uses Bock nibs, and the medium I received is a good one. I've had hit-or-miss experiences with Bock Nibs in the past, but I can't complain here. The black nib is coated, including the underside of the nib and tipping material, so there may be a brief period after you first receive the pen where there is slightly more feedback. I experienced this as the nib "squeaking" for the first page or so that I wrote, but it disappeared as the nib broke in. Again, I've noticed this on other PVC-coated nibs, and is nothing unique to this pen.

What I Didn't Like

Portability. Size is a double-edged sword. The Zero is very comfortable to write with, but it's not very portable. The length of the pen when capped makes it difficult to fit the Zero into certain pen cases and pen wraps, and it's impractical to carry in my pants pocket. This may be a personal preference, but when I think "minimalist pen," I think of something that I can slip in my jeans pocket and take anywhere on a moment's notice.
Wear on the Finish. The black coating on the aluminum looks great, but has a tendency to wear along sharp edges, especially the threads. I haven't used this pen that hard yet, and I expect to see similar chipping and flaking on the flat-end of the Zero.
Squeaky Threads. This issue is something that Trilogy is aware of, and has indicated that they have resolved in the final production specs. I'm not really sensitive to it, but some people have noticed a "nails-on-chalkboard" noise when you screw/unscrew the cap.
Marketing. I found the emphasis on "minimalism" in the Kickstarter marketing materials to be a bit over the top. ("A Minimal Fountain Pen Designed to Distill Writing to its Finest, Most Essential Form. A Seamless Link Between Mind and Reality.") That's a personal preference, though, and may speak to some people more than others.

Promotional photo for the Trilogy Zero fountain pen in silver (Courtesy of Trilogy Pens)

Should You Back this Kickstarter?

If you enjoy pens like the Namisu Nova, the Karas Kustoms Ink, or the Tactile Turn Gist, the Trilogy Zero caters to a similar niche. You should expect some of the issues I highlighted in this review to get ironed out as Trilogy finalizes their production specs. I consider the Zero a relatively low-risk Kickstarter project to back because the price of the pen is so reasonable. While Early Bird and Super Early Bird pricing is sold out, you can still pledge $60 and receive one Zero, or $105 and receive two. Pens are available in silver or black, with the option of a steel, gold plated, or coated black nib.

This price point also bodes well for Trilogy in the market as a whole. There's a relative dearth of quality fountain pens out there in the $50-75 price range, and if Trilogy continues to target the $55-$60 price point post-Kickstarter, they could really have something here.